U are not painting somthing u are taking out oil so where are the art in this? Its pure sience. There are no art or magic its only crap talk they make becuse most people dont understand science so its easyer to say art. Prove me wrong pleaseThis is a perfect example of a logical fallacy (false dilemma or false dichotomy) where the statement or question incorrectly assumes the answer is an either/or.
I personally think it both art and science, although I would lean much more heavily to it being an art.
That said, may be worth taking a step back. What exactly is the definition of science and art in this question?
Please explainI think art is related in everything that involves personal taste, some prefer it soaked, some not, it needs a lot of knowledge to distill but a little art is still needed
I see science as a creative process in the first place. To understand science you need to think. The thoughts have to evolve to progress the science. Other wise how else would we now be using ships made of Steele instead of wood...which was used for thousands of years in ship building?Is there any art i destilling oils? Answer nooooo
There are only science.
Is there any art one blending oils?
Yes
So what do u think people?
How people like diffrent smell is another thing, i mean its no any art on producing destilling only sciensI will define science as pure logic, like mathematics, 1 + 1 = 2, there is no other answer to that, for distillation i guess it would be extracting the most amount of undenatured molecule from the raw material.
But we are humans that have complex psychology so pure logic cannot apply to us as is, for example science says, fruits are good for me but if i'm not in the mood for a fruit maybe i wouldn't want to eat one, i would prefer a hamburger and maybe just maybe it would be bad for me to constantly repress my desire for a hamburger.
Same think for oils, logic would say that funk or barnyard smells are a bad think but lots of people enjoy that.
And the art is to appeal to some people tastes even if it's against logic.
Perhaps Abu Amir this could be best with an attempt at an answer if I were to understand your profile/definition of art.I want some one prove me when destilling there are art?
I want some one prove me when destilling there are art?
There are no art att all, if i put some one who is best on paint picture and told him here make me oil that dont smell burnd, he will not be abel to do it or he may do it but his artisinal talent are useless. If i say to a chemist i want oil without this substance becuse i dont like it he will do it 100%
So where are we
U are not painting somthing u are taking out oil so where are the art in this? Its pure sience. There are no art or magic its only crap talk they make becuse most people dont understand science so its easyer to say art. Prove me wrong please
But it is a most delightful thread you have started akh...Is there any art i destilling oils? Answer nooooo
There are only science.
Is there any art one blending oils?
Yes
So what do u think people?
So one is painted by the original artist and the other is created by the original tree. They are both artistic originals...Ok i will give u proove it is 100% sience
If u want an oil that is like oil name xxxxx
Becuse u like oil xxxxx
As sience they se wahat is xxxxx consist of and destill this oil to u exactley as xxxxx. But if u want me copy mona lisa picture i cant paint it maybe if i copy it but u will say its not the same becuse i have not painted
I hope people understand me
Hey man relax this is just a discussion forumDear Abu Amir, you haven’t offered any solid reasoning how distilling oud oil is cannot be an art. Nor have you provided any proof how distilling oil is 100% science.