ctruth

Oud Beginner
Hey guys,

did anybody buy alteyas rose ottto/absolute this year and can give me an opinion about it?

I read mixed reviews online, some good - some very bad, which immediately gave me red flags.

Thanks in advance
 
Hey guys,

did anybody buy alteyas rose ottto/absolute this year and can give me an opinion about it?

I read mixed reviews online, some good - some very bad, which immediately gave me red flags.

Thanks in advance
i've had mixed results… At one point their ottos were very fresh and tangy and beautiful and sometime around 2022 I started getting these more bland sweaty top note types, smelled less fresh and more like a kind of generic blended Rose oil aroma. Pleasant enough and very useful for blending but not really beautiful and sparkling on its own and it compared pretty poorly to what they had offered the previous years and very clearly fell short of several artisanal oils on blotter strips because of that kind of generic sweaty damascena off-note. Very curious to hear what the current batch is like…

The absolute was more consistent from year to year - I do feel like there were some batches that were more succulent than others but I didn't notice the same major change in quality like i did with the otto.
 
i've had mixed results… At one point their ottos were very fresh and tangy and beautiful and sometime around 2022 I started getting these more bland sweaty top note types, smelled less fresh and more like a kind of generic blended Rose oil aroma. Pleasant enough and very useful for blending but not really beautiful and sparkling on its own and it compared pretty poorly to what they had offered the previous years and very clearly fell short of several artisanal oils on blotter strips because of that kind of generic sweaty damascena off-note. Very curious to hear what the current batch is like…

The absolute was more consistent from year to year - I do feel like there were some batches that were more succulent than others but I didn't notice the same major change in quality like i did with the otto.
Thank you for this brother. It seems like they do not really care too much about quality control…
 
Thank you for this brother. It seems like they do not really care too much about quality control…
I don't know, it definitely seems like they changed something about the source or processing of the oil, or maybe it was something about the season and harvest for a couple of those years. I will likely order a sample of what they're selling one of these days just to see how it compares. Would love to get some of the stuff like I was getting in 2020/2021 if I'm remembering right
 
I don't know, it definitely seems like they changed something about the source or processing of the oil, or maybe it was something about the season and harvest for a couple of those years. I will likely order a sample of what they're selling one of these days just to see how it compares. Would love to get some of the stuff like I was getting in 2020/2021 if I'm remembering right
As far as I know, they have their own rose fields and a distillery in bulgaria.

Do you know any other authentic, high-quality supplier for rose oils?
 
As far as I know, they have their own rose fields and a distillery in bulgaria.

Do you know any other authentic, high-quality supplier for rose oils?
my understanding is they are kind of like a cooperative and their oils are the collected distillations of a number of different growers and farmers. I'm out of touch with the state of the industry but if I've got my story straight, at one point what they sold was a mixture of stuff that was field hydrodistilled by the farmers on the one hand and stuff that was steamed distilled in modern facilities on the other and it could be that changes in the ratio of those two types of oils could explain the difference. Would be nice if there were somebody here with some connection with producers in Bulgaria.

I have not restocked rose oil in a while and the last time I did I purchased ruh gulab which really is quite different from the Bulgarian type.

I would love to find another source of that classic rich lively peppery Bulgarian style oil at price is roughly in line with Alteya but I just haven't done the research of late and so I'm not sure who to recommend and don't have anyone based on my own experiences right now.

They do sell an organic Rose otto that is quite a bit more expensive than their conventional oil, that might be worth sampling if the price is not too high for your needs.

It's just a matter of time before somebody recommends hermitage.com so I might as well mention even though I can't vouch for that company personally. People who seem to really know their stuff speak highly of their rose offerings, I'm not sure where their price comes in relative to Alteya
 
my understanding is they are kind of like a cooperative and their oils are the collected distillations of a number of different growers and farmers. I'm out of touch with the state of the industry but if I've got my story straight, at one point what they sold was a mixture of stuff that was field hydrodistilled by the farmers on the one hand and stuff that was steamed distilled in modern facilities on the other and it could be that changes in the ratio of those two types of oils could explain the difference. Would be nice if there were somebody here with some connection with producers in Bulgaria.

I have not restocked rose oil in a while and the last time I did I purchased ruh gulab which really is quite different from the Bulgarian type.

I would love to find another source of that classic rich lively peppery Bulgarian style oil at price is roughly in line with Alteya but I just haven't done the research of late and so I'm not sure who to recommend and don't have anyone based on my own experiences right now.

They do sell an organic Rose otto that is quite a bit more expensive than their conventional oil, that might be worth sampling if the price is not too high for your needs.

It's just a matter of time before somebody recommends hermitage.com so I might as well mention even though I can't vouch for that company personally. People who seem to really know their stuff speak highly of their rose offerings, I'm not sure where their price comes in relative to Alteya
I dont know where to look right now either. The market seems too watered down, I started my journey last year and I am already annoyed by deep diving through the www to find authentic suppliers.

I once bought the Rose Bourbon absolue from hermitage, and I was not pleased to be honest. The quality of this absolute was poor.
 
Back
Top