Assalamu’Alaikum and greetings!

This is my first post in this great community and forum! I would like to thank everyone for the wonderful, honest, adventurous, cheerful, and knowledgeable discussions, which benefited me a ton! I am really grateful to you all - jazhakallahu khayr and thank you so much!

Growing up in a tropical country (Bangladesh), I have had the privilege of enjoying the natural fragrances of different flowers. Rose, Jasmine, Tuberose, and Night-blooming Jasmine are some of my favorites! I had a rose tree since when I was 5.

When I stepped in the U.S. in 2020 for my PhD degree, I started to miss the smell of flowers. My wife purchased a rose plant and it broke our heart by not giving any fragrance. Only last week I came across “fragrant” rose plant in Costco, first time in the U.S.

My first purchase in Ouddict was from SiberMusk in late 2024, which was a collection of some basic EOs for musk maceration. Smelling the Bulgarian Rose Damascena Otto for the first time put a wide smile on my face, SubhanAllah! I fell in love with that rose immediately.
Afterwards, I tried a few Ottos and one absolute among which my favorite is the Vintage Bulgarian Rose Oil (1995) from @mesOUD! Rose oil never fails to put a smile on my face whenever I wear it.

I haven’t been able to love rose absolute as much as I do Otto, especially since the solvent extraction brings out some leafy, herbaceous smell that I am not a fan of. I would like to explore all types of roses from different parts of the world, but my budget will take me a while before I can do that. I know about the general rule of thumb: ordering sample size for trial first. But I always fail to follow this one whenever I encounter a rose oil!

Where did you shop your best rose oils from? Any recommendation for under $100/gram would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance!
 
Last edited:
Which roses has a less green leafy stemmy profile and more of a lush, red, and jammy profile that's still a little tart for hot summers?
Lush red jammy sounds like rose absolute, if of good quality.
I have a sample of rose absolute from mesOud, and it's one of my most prized sample vials! It's got this almost guava like nuance, and reminds me of sniffing a rose bulb in my hand, fully in bloom. If you grew up with rose in your culture, it'll recall all those memories, of petals plucked off and put into baskets, digging your hand inside when no one was looking, and gently squeezing them to impart a scent on your fingers 🤤
 
I have a sample of rose absolute from mesOud, and it's one of my most prized sample vials! It's got this almost guava like nuance, and reminds me of sniffing a rose bulb in my hand, fully in bloom. If you grew up with rose in your culture, it'll recall all those memories, of petals plucked off and put into baskets, digging your hand inside when no one was looking, and gently squeezing them to impart a scent on your fingers 🤤
Sounds like it smells more green than red?
 
Sounds like it smells more green than red?
No actually, I'm referring to the fruity, tropical aspect of guava. Mr. P's right on the money, absolutes are about as jammy as rose will ever get. When I think of green I imagine Kashan rose oils (haven't had an absolute from there) but often rose oils in general are more aggressive citrus-y or aromatic in nature, absolutes feel more like you're having rose jam (Gulkand, if you're aware of it). Specifically absolutes also carry this sweetness which is only found in rose water and petals which for whatever reason never comes out in the rose oils
 
No actually, I'm referring to the fruity, tropical aspect of guava. Mr. P's right on the money, absolutes are about as jammy as rose will ever get. When I think of green I imagine Kashan rose oils (haven't had an absolute from there) but often rose oils in general are more aggressive citrus-y or aromatic in nature, absolutes feel more like you're having rose jam (Gulkand, if you're aware of it). Specifically absolutes also carry this sweetness which is only found in rose water and petals which for whatever reason never comes out in the rose oils
The centifolia absolute that @mesOUD carried was an especially sweet and jammy one, come to think of it. That unique petal-like sweetness is mostly PEA (phenyl ethyl alcohol) which is MUCH higher in the absolute because PEA is soluble in water to a larger degree than most aromatics and whenever you distill rose over water, the water soaks up the PEA and not much ends up in the oil. Not an issue with the absolute where water is not part of the process.

I would recommend trying more than one absolute because depending on the source they can vary quite a lot. If you want to experience a surprise order some phenyl ethyl alcohol natural isolate. You will likely not see rose absolute in the same way again after that.
 
Last edited:
The centifolia absolute that @mesOUD carried was an especially sweet and jammy one, come to think of it. That unique petal-like sweetness is mostly PEA (phenyl ethyl alcohol) which is MUCH higher in the absolute because PEA is soluble in water to a larger degree than most aromatics and whenever you distill rose over water, the water soaks up the PEA and not much ends up in the oil. Not an issue with the absolute where water is not part of the process.

I would recommend trying more than one absolute because depending on the source they can vary quite a lot. If you want to experience a surprise order some phenyl ethyl alcohol natural isolate. You will likely not see rose absolute in the same way again after that.
That's brilliant Mr. P! This answers the old question I had, of why rose water gives such a different profile compared to rose oils! Growing up I was more used to rose water, in some religious gatherings you'd have this guy with the pesticide sprayer on his back, misting the air and the attendants with rose water!

Along the same lines I was thinking about Sandali Gulab which is distilled on sandalwood and how most people seem to prefer it to Ruh Gulab, of course because of lower price but also because I'm sure certain compounds dissolve in the sandalwood oil which can't in the water. This also led me to take a sniff of Begum from @mesOUD once again, and I'm always taken aback by how different it smells to a blend, almost impossible to recreate I feel. It's also the reason I'm pretty sure I love Ottoman Empire IV because if I recall correctly, there's a good dose of a Hindi oud distilled with rose water, thus capturing some of the nuance which only the absolute or the phenyl ethyl alcohol can only bring in!

Also this gives me a reason to spend some time with the brilliant rose water @An Najwa procured during his travels! I used to think of rose water as an inferior product, but once again, our nose has led us to the conclusion, that that's much more than meets the eye! I'll make sure to keep an eye out for the natural isolate of phenyl ethyl alcohol, as well as some absolute of Turkish rose, and surrounding regions.
 
Last edited:
Forgot to add this to my last post, but there's a nuance of the absolute I feel in Ajmal's Mukhallat Dehn al Oud Moattaq, the oil specifically which I wore a little while back. Even in the spray there's something which makes it feel different to the other rose fragrances on the market. Even in the cult classic of 2022 Ibraheem al Quershi's Blue Oud there was a piercing sweet pink rose note which was addicting, and completely parallel to how I had smelled rose being used till that point.

Perfume supply house described phenyl ethyl alcohol has having a bready facet, which is completely in line with a sort of yeasty scent I get in the middle stages of Ottoman Empire IV when I spray it on my shirt, however that's not present in the Ajmal's.

Time for a couple days of mad swiping, spraying and note taking 🖖
 
That's brilliant Mr. P! This answers the old question I had, of why rose water gives such a different profile compared to rose oils! Growing up I was more used to rose water, in some religious gatherings you'd have this guy with the pesticide sprayer on his back, misting the air and the attendants with rose water!
Feeling nostalgic! I always loved the rose water spray session during milad/mahfil.
My first sniff of rose otto hit different than the rose water and yesterday I was thinking about it while sniffing different kinds of rose Ottos I have collected so far. MesOud’s absolute is definitely rich and I enjoy its detailed notes thoroughly.

For me, Bulgarian Otto has changed the way I used to look at rose. While the rich, sweeter profile of absolutes brings back memories, ottos hit me stronger with their more refined top citrusy notes, creating an uplifting vibe that lasts long enough to set the mode. I have made my own Sandali Gulab with all the rose oils I have and it’s been my most frequently used oil so far (obviously affordability is a factor here)!
 
I wonder if I've ever smelled a really good CO2 of Rose because the ones that I have smelled I have not cared for. There is some weird sweet waxy note that is not part of the typical Rose oil profile in the two specimens that have come my way. I feel like there must be amazing ones out there though because you would think this would capture the true fresh essence of the flower.
 
I have a sample of rose absolute from mesOud, and it's one of my most prized sample vials! It's got this almost guava like nuance, and reminds me of sniffing a rose bulb in my hand, fully in bloom. If you grew up with rose in your culture, it'll recall all those memories, of petals plucked off and put into baskets, digging your hand inside when no one was looking, and gently squeezing them to impart a scent on your fingers 🤤
Gosh, that sounds good
 
Assalamu’Alaikum and greetings!

This is my first post in this great community and forum! I would like to thank everyone for the wonderful, honest, adventurous, cheerful, and knowledgeable discussions, which benefited me a ton! I am really grateful to you all - jazhakallahu khayr and thank you so much!

Growing up in a tropical country (Bangladesh), I have had the privilege of enjoying the natural fragrances of different flowers. Rose, Jasmine, Tuberose, and Night-blooming Jasmine are some of my favorites! I had a rose tree since when I was 5.

When I stepped in the U.S. in 2020 for my PhD degree, I started to miss the smell of flowers. My wife purchased a rose plant and it broke our heart by not giving any fragrance. Only last week I came across “fragrant” rose plant in Costco, first time in the U.S.

My first purchase in Ouddict was from SiberMusk in late 2024, which was a collection of some basic EOs for musk maceration. Smelling the Bulgarian Rose Damascena Otto for the first time put a wide smile on my face, SubhanAllah! I fell in love with that rose immediately.
Afterwards, I tried a few Ottos and one absolute among which my favorite is the Vintage Bulgarian Rose Oil (1995) from @mesOUD! Rose oil never fails to put a smile on my face whenever I wear it.

I haven’t been able to love rose absolute as much as I do Otto, especially since the solvent extraction brings out some leafy, herbaceous smell that I am not a fan of. I would like to explore all types of roses from different parts of the world, but my budget will take me a while before I can do that. I know about the general rule of thumb: ordering sample size for trial first. But I always fail to follow this one whenever I encounter a rose oil!

Where did you shop your best rose oils from? Any recommendation for under $100/gram would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance!

Hello and welcome !

I hope it is ok to answer such a question directly : May I recommend ours ?

It is a genuinely wonderful oil, all done artisanally and traditionally.

The oil is produced via multiple slow heat low pressure hydrodistllation cycles that extract the heavier volatiles. We cultivate the orchard ourselves entirely naturally. Much more explanations on site for all the nerdy details what make the oil special, including on the social and ecological aspects of production.

We produce damascena, but are also slowly developing other things (centifolia, first distillations).

We have sold our rose to a couple of wonderful resident artisans here, in case.
 
Hello and welcome !

I hope it is ok to answer such a question directly : May I recommend ours ?

It is a genuinely wonderful oil, all done artisanally and traditionally.

The oil is produced via multiple slow heat low pressure hydrodistllation cycles that extract the heavier volatiles. We cultivate the orchard ourselves entirely naturally. Much more explanations on site for all the nerdy details what make the oil special, including on the social and ecological aspects of production.

We produce damascena, but are also slowly developing other things (centifolia, first distillations).

We have sold our rose to a couple of wonderful resident artisans here, in case.
Can you provide a link to your website? I sometimes lose track of who's who around here...
 
On my device I don't see any signatures for any members in fact!
oh ok, thanks for the feedback !

here on this pc I see them, including yours (just followed your insta, mine is not super active I am not really good at that stuff but post from time to time still)

added edit : nice content ! I enjoy the textual content in the captions. In your experience are people reading them ? (of course there will be all answers, but like enough to make it worth: I was asking myself this question lately)
 
oh ok, thanks for the feedback !

here on this pc I see them, including yours (just followed your insta, mine is not super active I am not really good at that stuff but post from time to time still)

added edit : nice content ! I enjoy the textual content in the captions. In your experience are people reading them ? (of course there will be all answers, but like enough to make it worth: I was asking myself this question lately)

It's a good question. Would be a shame if I'm just babbling into the void...

As it turns out I have had several comments from folks that they appreciated my approach to posting captions, and I figure they each represent at least a handful of people who might feel similarly. i've connected with quite a few nice people as well this way!
 
Back
Top