Got it, so can enhanced liberation from cellular matrix be followed with heat in presence of oxygen donors to yield the desired profile?
Is it possible to design co-solvent system to exclude the undesirable waxes and plant molecules from extraction?
Maybe not Natural DES systems, but similar?
Scale up to pilot then industrial is never simple, isn't that the task of chemical engineers? Design large scale implementation of the frivolous ideas floating in the minds of the dreamers?
 
Coming at this from a less scientific angle, I have a few thoughts…

The difference between the smell of the room temperature wood and the aroma of the essential oil (and for that matter of the smoke/vapor from combusting oud) tells me that the chemicals that we love in the oil and smoke are not really there in the wood itself in the same form. I don't think this is merely liberating trapped volatiles but rather some kind of heat driven transformation in the presence of oxygen. It's not like rosemary, where the crushed plant has the same pungent smell as the essential oil more or less.

I am guessing prolonged distillations produces unique aroma chemicals that are not found in the wood itself due to chemical changes driven by the elevated temperature (especially given the very mild aroma of CO2 extracts of non-kinam wood). I feel like this is a little bit of a tangent from the thread here but I am mystified by this aspect of oud.

I recall seeing GCMS reports and a newsletter from White Lotus aromatics years ago highlighting the difference in chemical profile of long distilled sandalwood versus short, with the long distillation having all kinds of additional molecules that basically were the results of transformation due to chemical change
This is a scenario that is too different from the traditional essential oil extraction yield or quality point of view. When I was responding @mesOUD, I avoided bringing up that discourse, as it would have required some effort and time to write and shed light on that angle. You have just brought it back here again. It was already scientifically proven that the chemical profile from agarwood burning and agarwood essential oil from hydrodistillation or any other distillation is not the same. Distillation time and many more factors play into the final product. Because we know the long hydro-distillation product appeals to many of us, it does not necessarily seal the deal that a very short, different kind of extraction will not result in a nice product.
A very likeable top note from the agarwood might be released with specific physical-chemical thermal conditions that might be altogether lost during long hydrodistillation and could be captured with another method that we do not know yet. Again, some low-scent-profile molecules may convert into fantastic scent molecules in another process. The same is true for some low-volatility molecules. As I mentioned earlier in another comment, a minor chemical imbalance may also destroy the whole thing. All I am saying is you have highlighted a valid point, and there are many more of those still waiting to be examined. Who knows what is waiting in the corner from a new piece of research, either well-thought-out or serendipitous? So, we must not hold back researching further just because the current approach is working fine for us and we are happy about it. We should not hold back our curiosity-driven thoughts, no matter how wild or trivial they are!
 
Last edited:
(No AI was used in any way - all researched with my own brain 🙂
There is quite a bit of ongoing research worldwide on the subject, and while the NADES (natural deep eutectic solvents) seem very promising on the laboratory level of research for the extraction of aromatic essences, their practical commercial application proves to be more challenging, for a number of (so far crucial) factors:
High viscosity of their mixes requires very specific new (and pretty sophisticated) equipment and new technology to operate it - which means also a completely new professional training for producers, which means such novelty requires significant investments, to shift the whole industry - a very big challenge, particularly in the traditional rural locations of aromatic industry;
Water adversely influences the solubility powers of many of these complex mixtures of solvents (made up from 3 to over 20 different solvents), and many of raw aromatic materials contain considerable amounts of water in them, thus interfering negatively with the solubility and making the process fickle and unevenly vacillating;
NADES dissolve not only aromatic compounds but also many other non-volatile biochemicals, and that complicates already complicated issue of the post-extraction separation; temeprature (heat) would help but these solvents' mixtures are very adversely impacted by heat, so no heat ought be involved - which is another issue;
Energy consumption for the entire chain of the processes, including the reprocessing of the solvents - is another significant challenge - paired with the requirement of the novel equipment for it - simply saying, unlike with traditional steam distillations, you can not lit the wood with fire and let the water simmer - you need special equipment (and strict monitoring) for everything.
Lastly, tradition is a something that takes time to establsih, and while NADES seem to be very promising and conceptually simple, it is also not a very elegant, rather complicated in practical sense, demanding (also intellectually) and not very intuitive - 'clumsy' technology on the operative level - so far, which makes it not easily adaptable (and adoptable) at the wide commercial scale.
But I am sure that in the future, with a few practical stream-lining tweaks, deep eutectic solvents' tech will find its way and will have a range of NADES-extracted essential oils.
So far I've found none on the wide global market...
N.B. Here is a link to a very recent (less than a year ago) survey of numerous studues into NADES extractions made by Spanish-Colombian team, published in the periodic called 'Molecules':
This is a very interesting paper. Leads me to other publications as well.
Thank You again Sir.
 
Good Morning
I shouldn't think about this when I am in the office at work but this topic is preying on my mind.
To simplify what I hear as follows: Right now the DES or NADES solvent systems trials equate to placing some sliced brisket on a grill with barbecue sauce for 20 minutes, while a longer distillation with water equates to placing entire brisket in a smoker for 24 to 30 hours. I guess both can be called BBQ, but clearly the end products are worlds apart.
The time and temperature are integral to the process of producing the complex profile desired in an Oudh oil just as is necessary for great BBQ......
 
Coming at this from a less scientific angle, I have a few thoughts…

The difference between the smell of the room temperature wood and the aroma of the essential oil (and for that matter of the smoke/vapor from combusting oud) tells me that the chemicals that we love in the oil and smoke are not really there in the wood itself in the same form. I don't think this is merely liberating trapped volatiles but rather some kind of heat driven transformation in the presence of oxygen. It's not like rosemary, where the crushed plant has the same pungent smell as the essential oil more or less.

I am guessing prolonged distillations produces unique aroma chemicals that are not found in the wood itself due to chemical changes driven by the elevated temperature (especially given the very mild aroma of CO2 extracts of non-kinam wood). I feel like this is a little bit of a tangent from the thread here but I am mystified by this aspect of oud.

I recall seeing GCMS reports and a newsletter from White Lotus aromatics years ago highlighting the difference in chemical profile of long distilled sandalwood versus short, with the long distillation having all kinds of additional molecules that basically were the results of transformation due to chemical change
Thinking about the CO2 extracts clarified the subject greatly.
Like "BBQ" I suppose. Some folks slice up some meat, pour "BBQ" sauce on top, throw it on the gas grill for 10 -20 minutes, invite you over for BBQ! Others rub the brisket in seasoning, place it in the smoker for 24-30 hours, lovingly tend to it as needed, and HOPEFULLY invite you over for BBQ!
Same meat as substrate, different processes with totally different end product.

My innate desire to pigeon hole items into orderly equations, probabilities etc. sometimes hinders me from seeing the forest due to the trees....sort of
Time to relax and just enjoy the product for what it is, stop analyzing! Analysis in and of itself is almost an addiction for some people (ME for instance), detracts from pure enjoyment.
Please do not think I am trying to state that Oud is equivalent to BBQ, it was a simple way to wrap my mind around the process variables. Nor does my reply insinuate that I want an Oudh oil that smells like my dog peed on a mesquite tree on a very hot, West Texas afternoon.
 
Back
Top