I recently got two others from their daily range and they're both quite terrible. Golden Pavillion smells like perfume and Eternal Treasure just smells like a sharp burning wood. Not nice at all. I've noticed no one on here ever really makes a comment on scents that they don't like? Maybe we should start a thread for that? Or would that be too controversial? I mean we can't all like everything yeah?
I’m not particularly crazy about their daily collection myself. As far as negative reviews go, I do think a lot of people take the tactic of “if you don’t have something nice to say, don’t say it“
I think the fact that this is a vendor sponsored website contributes to that, you definitely have to read between the lines or ask people directly if you are trying to figure out what to avoid. The focus on the positive does avoid some of the discord that plagued some of the older forums.
I share your concern about it though and for myself what I do is:
1) if I think it is fake, I will notify the vendor and generally toss the oil into the trash and that’s the end of it. Vendors to handle it however they think is right.
2) if it seems authentic, but it’s not outstanding I will usually just write a descriptive review without any words suggesting it is wonderful, outstanding, or unique. Sometimes I will tell the vendor sometimes not depending on the individual and the situation.
3) if I like it or if I think it is one of a kind or is an exemplar of some particular scent, I will always say that and probably repeat it not as a rhetorical technique, but out of actual enthusiasm.
4) if I’ve heard from multiple people I trust that a particular source has knowingly sold them fake materials I just steer clear altogether so i won’t have anything to review (definitely do not want to imply that just because I don’t write about the oils from some source means i have some reason not to….
5) no bull: a lot of what I have received is after communication with vendors and after someone I trust has vouched for them, and so honestly the majority of what I get is quality stuff.
In the “old days” when folks were buying stuff from eBay Singapore it was very hit and miss and discussing on a forum with no connection to those vendors at all it was much easier to say “don’t buy xxxx hindi double super oud it smells like an ashtray”.