Amberbreens

Oud Fan
Hello again,

so I have a lil' problem - I ordered something that was advertised as "100% ambergris essential oil" on ebay from a company called "CEinternational". 5 ml for around 40 € + 20 shipping - I know, I should've known better, but I simply wanted to know.

But what they sent me is SOO obviously not ambergris, not in the slightest way, and they even sell it showing pictures of real ambergris pieces writing in the description about sperm whale secretion etc.

What I got was the typical strong of labdanum/storax smelling "amber" fragrance, that smells like incense, hippie perfume etc.

It was quite a hassle to get them to refund, as they say their supplier says it's 100% ambergris, they themselves do not know better.

Now they are asking me if I can come up with some proof of what their liquid is containing as they want to complain to their supplier and he won't accept "someone says it doesn't smell like ambergris" just like that.

They thought they could silence me by saying that in natural perfumery scents develop differently and that this is not pure ambergris but a maceration in jojoba ( haha 😆 😄 😜 exactly what I'm doing at home) - so they really ain't got no clue.

So do you have an idea of whom I could send it to and who could proof that there is no ambergris present? Someone in Europe maybe?

Or you have another idea of how I could solve this?

Greets
Ambergris
 
Hi @Amberbreens, if you're sure, the product is a mix of labdanum/vanilla/benzoin, can you guess what the proportions are? If the Labdanum is in the highest proportion in the mixture, it will not be so difficult to prove. If you could send me 0.5ml of a sample, I can try a couple of quick tests.
 
Hi @Amberbreens, if you're sure, the product is a mix of labdanum/vanilla/benzoin, can you guess what the proportions are? If the Labdanum is in the highest proportion in the mixture, it will not be so difficult to prove. If you could send me 0.5ml of a sample, I can try a couple of quick tests.
I could send you all of it as I don't need this stuff/have enough of these kinds of "amber". I would not swear the main ingredient is labdanum, could also contain just as much benzoe, but to me it smells mostly of labdanum.
The shop owner said, they're offer labdanum oil also and it smelled quite different to them - they really at least behaved like they're willing to solvent this and getting it tested with ftir at least and offered to show me the results then - but this is now quite some weeks ago (since I posted first time on it) and nothing happened - item is still sold as "100 % ambergris essential oil" with pictures of ambergris.

Funny thing is - I offered to send them a tiny bit of my real ambergris so they can smell what it actually smells like. They're answer was "yes cool, we'd only need a couple grams" 😄 🤣 😂 They don't even know shit about the value of ambergris - I thought about a tiny crumb of maybe 0.1 grams, just so they get an idea of the actual smell.

They're not answering my messages anymore now - thinking about complaining to ebay because of label fraud.

But maaybe they send me the wrong item - that just came to my mind the other day, as the bottle they sent me is labeled "Amber" and not "Ambergris", while they actually done offer an amber oil AND this ambergris oil, so maybe they sent me the amber instead, which is either the tree resin or an amber-accord, which is exactly what the thing they've sent me smells like.

But - I highly doubt that, as the reviews on the "100 % pure ambergris esential oil" are absolutely positive, written by "normal" people who just use it directly as perfume oil or room fragrance, all saying that it smells divine and like incense - that is first no description of ambergris and second would normal Etsy customers not find that real ambergris smells good. There is only ONE bad review of someone saying that he asked quite a few experts and all of them said it would smell nothing like ambergris.

Anyhow - it's not really important, I got my refund (well minus 20 € for shipping) and I for myself know what it is. It's primarily entertainment to me now, proving to them, they're selling crap and being fooled themselves by their supplier. I'd just love to know their reaction after actually having it tested, maybe they did and now they're embarrassed, but then I wonder how they could have the audacity to still sell it as real ambergris.

Thanks so far
Sabrina
 
Back
Top