Very interesting and introspective thread. Initially I thought to jump in to defend barn but I realized dark Brandon helped me uncover a related question - are there universally known hallmarks of poor quality oud oil (assuming pure oud wood was used)? An oversimplified opinion is barn is low quality which we know to be untrue through many examples. However, there are certainly some off notes or compositions that create distaste for an oil for me- over-ripe fruitiness of Cambodis, dead flat melon of plantation sinensis, bad balance between barn and leather/honey, burnt notes, roasted peanut notes etc. I used to associate these with poor quality distillations but think the responses here helped me realize these ideas are more subjective than I previously thought.
Great question. I'm not qualified to answer, but I'd second being interested in the answer. I imagine the answer is 'its complex', especially when you add in poor distillation of good wood and good distillation of poor wood. The answer may be less in whats present as signs of poor wood and possibly more what's missing. I'd be surprised if the difference though was 'good balance' vs 'bad balance' of various notes, as I'd suspect thats more a taste call, and a matter of the quality of wood+distillation+terrior+style as a whole, but I bet there are some specifics to be learned other than 'plantation is simple, and good wild is complex' level that is true, but not terribly useful (imo)

I have the 'oud rating' book that was published recently, but I'll admit, I havn't really read through it other than a few brief sections, and it seemed a bit very high level about it rather than specifics.
 
Top