Eden are a large essential oils company and testing etc represents a fraction of their costs. Moreover they operate in a mature industry. The challenges for small scale artisans are different. But we have to rise to the challenge in a way that is appropriate for us.
 
Eden are a large essential oils company and testing etc represents a fraction of their costs. Moreover they operate in a mature industry. The challenges for small scale artisans are different. But we have to rise to the challenge in a way that is appropriate for us.
100% and if I was making finest agarwood direct from woodchips, and had a market for it and someone came up to me and said "I challenge you to prove it's real" I might say "buzz off"! There is a place for people who don't need to bother with testing as well, that's for each person to figure out individually! 🙂
 
100% and if I was making finest agarwood direct from woodchips, and had a market for it and someone came up to me and said "I challenge you to prove it's real" I might say "buzz off"! There is a place for people who don't need to bother with testing as well, that's for each person to figure out individually! 🙂

Exactly. @Al Hashimi have oils that cost over $3000 for 2.5g and the batches are small. Some less than 15g. Sparing even a gram for testing is impossible. Even the oil is $1000 and there is not much, it is still expensive and at these price ranges, the customer certainly won't be footing the bill.
 
Fascinating discussion going on. Just to affirm,

1. GC-MS testing would not be needed for more than one drop of oil. I have refined my screening method, and now it requires no more than a drop of oil, unless it is too sticky to swipe from the vial.

2. Although my method is not as sensitive as GC-MS to detect a tiny other natural product added to an authentic oil, it is good enough to detect the presence of any synthetic compound in commercial oil. The main advantage of my method is that results are instantaneous and cost a fraction of GC-MS testing.

3. I have mentioned it a couple of times elsewhere that just getting a GC-MS report along with an oil from a vendor would mean nothing to a customer, as there is no guarantee that the exact oil is sold for which oil GC-MS report was generated, given the current GC-MS report marketing trend with oil. I have shown in a different thread (https://www.ouddict.com/threads/gcms-reports-and-eden-botanicals-oudh-oil-a-quick-fact-check.7586) how Eden Botanics is dishonest when handing over a GC-MS report to a customer, which, 3 out of 4 times, has no relation to the batch of oil sold.

4. On the other hand, I can give numerous examples, when I asked to purchase a non-standard small amount of oil from well-established companies for GC-MS testing, they refused to sell because they do not wish to test the samples by a company with which they do not have commercial relations. Over the last three days, I have approached at least 30 (a mix of low- and high-profile) online vendors to purchase a small amount of oil for quality checking; only two responded positively. So, even honest retailers fear quality checks, as an open, publicly accessible testing result may undermine their brand's perceived value to customers compared to competitors', as @Mr.P mentioned earlier.

So, there are far more reasons than just the cost of testing alone why traders are reluctant to have their oils tested openly by a third party.
 
Last edited:
Fascinating discussion going on. Just to affirm,

1. GC-MS testing would not be needed for more than one drop of oil. I have refined my screening method, and now it requires no more than a drop of oil, unless it is too sticky to swipe from the vial.

2. Although my method is not as sensitive as GC-MS to detect a tiny other natural product added to an authentic oil, it is good enough to detect any synthetic oil in commercial oil. The plus point of my method is that the results are instantaneous and cost a fraction of GC-MS testing.

3. I have mentioned it a couple of times elsewhere that just getting a GC-MS report along with an oil from a vendor would mean nothing to a customer, as there is no guarantee that the exact oil is sold for which oil GC-MS report was generated, given the current GC-MS report marketing trend with oil. I have shown in a different thread (https://www.ouddict.com/threads/gcms-reports-and-eden-botanicals-oudh-oil-a-quick-fact-check.7586) how Eden Botanics is dishonest when handing over a GC-MS report to a customer, which, 3 out of 4 times, has no relation to the batch of oil sold.

4. On the other hand, I can give numerous examples, when I asked to purchase a non-standard small amount of oil from well-established companies for GC-MS testing, they refused to sell because they do not wish to test the samples by a company with which they do not have commercial relations. Over the last three days, I have approached at least 30 (a mix of low- and high-profile) online vendors to purchase a small amount of oil for quality checking; only two responded positively. So, even honest retailers fear quality checks, as they may undermine their brand's perceived value to customers compared to competitors', as @Mr.P mentioned earlier.

So, there are far more reasons than just the cost of testing alone why traders are reluctant to have their oils tested openly by a third party.

I think focusing on the cost of the test is maybe not getting at the core issue. It's the cost of having your entire inventory come up positive for phtalates or elemi fractions or aetoxylon. Someone would have to be in a pretty unique position to be having a small business and willing to take the risk of having just their business get scrutinized on a highly technical level, using a tool that was not available to them when making their own purchase decisions. Who is going to be able to take that hit? You'd have have to find somebody for whom the business is of no relevance to their financial well-being I guess...

I wonder… Maybe if you contacted successful artisanal perfumers who wanted to be able to advertise that their ingredients received some additional level of scrutiny and thus offer greater safety or quality? you might find people with some inventory that they want tested but for whom the risk is lower because they are not in the business of selling oud.
 
A lot to digest here.

My two cents here in regards to:
Are you relating the price tag to Facts, Fiction or Lies???

For me the price tag comes down to enjoyment. I tend to stay with physical wood pieces this way I can see nature at work. The value/ price tag is in my enjoyment.

Trust often trumps facts, fiction and lies…. I may trust what you say you think is true when in fact it is not. Does that make it fiction, maybe but not a lie,,, nobody wants to be lied to and when that happens trust is gone.
 
I would love to have some woods I have carbon dated.
Would I enjoy them more knowing the age
No.
Because I would probably sell them $$$$. They would Be gone no more enjoying


My apologies, if I am straying . I am a science person myself. But science doesn’t answer everything.

Price tag….is very subjective

What’s it worth to you.

A front row Taylor swift ticket to
Me is worth nothing, but to a fan $$$$!

I wonder how science would evaluate that.

it’s only worth what someone will pay…. Fact, fiction or lie.

Trust in science. It’s only part of it.
 
I’m about to take a look at 50 or more oud oils and 40 or so sandalwood oils in my collection to see how many are adulterated. Huge selection from a variety of suppliers. Stay tuned!
 
I’m about to take a look at 50 or more oud oils and 40 or so sandalwood oils in my collection to see how many are adulterated. Huge selection from a variety of suppliers. Stay tuned!
amazing
 
This should help you decide what actually deserves to go into your coffee 😄
[Ouddict.com] Are you relating the price tag to Facts, Fiction or Lies?
 
Sometimes I closely follow a few interesting topics here solely to learn something new. Unfortunately, I get disappointed almost every occasion. The junk inside of each topic gets heavier as the discussion moves forward, and sometimes even the plot is lost altogether. So, the questions arise: am I really educating myself by spending time here, or is a misconception even unconsciously injected into my brain? Well, I am not criticising Ouddict for its openness to accommodate opinions from every corner. It is even the opposite; I could not even stand reading some other blogs outside this forum for the stuff described on those online boards. The main concern for me is whether open, unmoderated postings lean more toward fruitful education or can spread misconceptions, fantasies, or even outright lies.
View attachment 51116
I know this is not a scientific journal, and there is no liability to stick only to the facts. Fiction is also an essential part of humankind's progress. Otherwise, we would not pay to go to the theatre. Yet, we watch that film knowing each character is nothing but fiction. So, when the actor or actress behaves differently in real life than in the film, it does not hurt us. But in the case of perfume or essential oil description, when the facts, fiction, and lies take a single trajectory into a space defying all gravity of reality, and for that 4D fictitious journey, the storyteller charges the customers whatever they like; there is no fixed price like a theatre ticket. What is even worse is that customers are given the impression they will watch a documentary produced by the Attenborough team. Yes, there is always a place for imagination and extrapolation based on facts and experience, but when imagination and fiction blur and gradually lead customers into a dark chamber filled with lies and deception, it suffocates me. Weeks before, when I was in Paris and walking through a street in the perfumery district, I stepped into a shop that was decorated in such a way that, inside, it felt like a spaceship film set, another world. When I smelled a few Oudh perfumes from that outlet, they were as ordinary as anything. Yet the saleswomen's lies and deception were meant to cover up the product's flaws. It gave me such a distaste for that elite work of light and decoration; I quickly walked off. So, what is the way forward not to fall into the trap of lies that are polished with imagination and fiction?

There is no alternative to the pure work of science. When I started my journey to verify the authenticity of agarwood oil and implement measures to protect the welfare of both honest entrepreneurs and customers, I expected a warm welcome from both sides. But reality is harsh. Customers are more inclined to fiction than to the unpolished truth. If I had expected support, by now so many nice facts would have been revealed, even outbidding some of the fictions circulating in the market now. But never mind, moving forward is the only solution for the time being. Yet, I can leave here some of my imagination, based on scientific facts, to draw a line between fiction and lies alike. If it does help with your purchase decision for your next oil, then I would say spending some of my time on this journey is not totally wasted, and your valuable time reading this nonsense. Here are some of my hypotheses or imagination on oil characteristics, whatever you prefer to call it:

1. All types of natural oils have a common characteristic.

2. All species of agarwood oil have a typical character. The oil of each agarwood species has its own chemical fingerprint, regardless of the region where it is grown. Each agarwood species may have different varieties; each variety shows its own regional chemical fingerprint captured in the oil. For each variety or species, the wild and various artificial methods impart their own signature to the developed agarwood character and, hence, to the final oil.

3. If one adds another type of oil to agarwood oil, the common characteristic of agarwood oil becomes distorted. Without GC-MS testing, it is not possible to know what kind of other natural product is added, but you will surely know either by sniffing or spectroscopic fingerprinting.

4. It does not matter what type of distillation method one uses; a common chemical fingerprint of agarwood oil (such as A. A. crassna) will not be lost.

5. It does not matter if one uses a very low-quality or double super quality wood of a specific species; a common chemical fingerprint of that species will always remain in the oil.

6. If the same distillation pot is used to distil a different quality of the same agarwood species for a period of time without a complete wash or cleaning of the vessel, there will be a distinct fingerprint character of the pot remaining in each oil. In other words, different distillation pots put their signature on their oil. I caught a few distillers telling lies as if someone else's oil was their own, because I already recognised the fingerprint of their pot in some of their previous oil. I have not scientifically proven this in any peer-reviewed paper, but I am happy to put in my two cents on the outcome of this bet.

7. A chemical fingerprint and the olfactory fingerprint are not the same thing to confuse. All the features I mentioned above relate to the chemical fingerprint. GC-MS is not sufficient to capture the olfactory characteristics of each oil, but it is effective at detecting chemical fingerprints. So, with GC-MS, it is not easy to determine the olfactory quality of an oil, but it is easy to detect even a drop of non-agarwood oil adulteration in one tula.

8. Detecting the presence of a tiny amount of synthetic compounds in any type of oil, including agarwood oil, is as easy as pie with any reported analytical method, including GC-MS.

9. Capturing the best olfactory quality in the distilled oil is a combination of raw material quality, distillation apparatus features and the skill of the operator. So the outcome depends on many permutations and combinations. Yet, no matter how good or bad any of those parameters are controlled, a chemical signature of authentic oil will never be lost in the final oil. So, suppose a distiller or trader tries to blame a counterfeit or adulterated oil on any of those parameters to cover up wrongdoing. In that case, it is impossible to hide the evidence of its criminality.

10: The Chemical fingerprinting of an oil is as substantial as its wood DNA fingerprint if both are derived from the same piece of plant material.
View attachment 51118
How many of you think these perfumes are the same as stated on the labels?

Can you use these same test for the actual wood, not the oil, to determine species?

If so. How much wood is needed.

The science part of my mind has awoken and knowing is part of enjoying as well…
 
Last edited:
Sometimes I closely follow a few interesting topics here solely to learn something new. Unfortunately, I get disappointed almost every occasion. The junk inside of each topic gets heavier as the discussion moves forward, and sometimes even the plot is lost altogether. So, the questions arise: am I really educating myself by spending time here, or is a misconception even unconsciously injected into my brain? Well, I am not criticising Ouddict for its openness to accommodate opinions from every corner. It is even the opposite; I could not even stand reading some other blogs outside this forum for the stuff described on those online boards. The main concern for me is whether open, unmoderated postings lean more toward fruitful education or can spread misconceptions, fantasies, or even outright lies.
View attachment 51116
I know this is not a scientific journal, and there is no liability to stick only to the facts. Fiction is also an essential part of humankind's progress. Otherwise, we would not pay to go to the theatre. Yet, we watch that film knowing each character is nothing but fiction. So, when the actor or actress behaves differently in real life than in the film, it does not hurt us. But in the case of perfume or essential oil description, when the facts, fiction, and lies take a single trajectory into a space defying all gravity of reality, and for that 4D fictitious journey, the storyteller charges the customers whatever they like; there is no fixed price like a theatre ticket. What is even worse is that customers are given the impression they will watch a documentary produced by the Attenborough team. Yes, there is always a place for imagination and extrapolation based on facts and experience, but when imagination and fiction blur and gradually lead customers into a dark chamber filled with lies and deception, it suffocates me. Weeks before, when I was in Paris and walking through a street in the perfumery district, I stepped into a shop that was decorated in such a way that, inside, it felt like a spaceship film set, another world. When I smelled a few Oudh perfumes from that outlet, they were as ordinary as anything. Yet the saleswomen's lies and deception were meant to cover up the product's flaws. It gave me such a distaste for that elite work of light and decoration; I quickly walked off. So, what is the way forward not to fall into the trap of lies that are polished with imagination and fiction?

There is no alternative to the pure work of science. When I started my journey to verify the authenticity of agarwood oil and implement measures to protect the welfare of both honest entrepreneurs and customers, I expected a warm welcome from both sides. But reality is harsh. Customers are more inclined to fiction than to the unpolished truth. If I had expected support, by now so many nice facts would have been revealed, even outbidding some of the fictions circulating in the market now. But never mind, moving forward is the only solution for the time being. Yet, I can leave here some of my imagination, based on scientific facts, to draw a line between fiction and lies alike. If it does help with your purchase decision for your next oil, then I would say spending some of my time on this journey is not totally wasted, and your valuable time reading this nonsense. Here are some of my hypotheses or imagination on oil characteristics, whatever you prefer to call it:

1. All types of natural oils have a common characteristic.

2. All species of agarwood oil have a typical character. The oil of each agarwood species has its own chemical fingerprint, regardless of the region where it is grown. Each agarwood species may have different varieties; each variety shows its own regional chemical fingerprint captured in the oil. For each variety or species, the wild and various artificial methods impart their own signature to the developed agarwood character and, hence, to the final oil.

3. If one adds another type of oil to agarwood oil, the common characteristic of agarwood oil becomes distorted. Without GC-MS testing, it is not possible to know what kind of other natural product is added, but you will surely know either by sniffing or spectroscopic fingerprinting.

4. It does not matter what type of distillation method one uses; a common chemical fingerprint of agarwood oil (such as A. A. crassna) will not be lost.

5. It does not matter if one uses a very low-quality or double super quality wood of a specific species; a common chemical fingerprint of that species will always remain in the oil.

6. If the same distillation pot is used to distil a different quality of the same agarwood species for a period of time without a complete wash or cleaning of the vessel, there will be a distinct fingerprint character of the pot remaining in each oil. In other words, different distillation pots put their signature on their oil. I caught a few distillers telling lies as if someone else's oil was their own, because I already recognised the fingerprint of their pot in some of their previous oil. I have not scientifically proven this in any peer-reviewed paper, but I am happy to put in my two cents on the outcome of this bet.

7. A chemical fingerprint and the olfactory fingerprint are not the same thing to confuse. All the features I mentioned above relate to the chemical fingerprint. GC-MS is not sufficient to capture the olfactory characteristics of each oil, but it is effective at detecting chemical fingerprints. So, with GC-MS, it is not easy to determine the olfactory quality of an oil, but it is easy to detect even a drop of non-agarwood oil adulteration in one tula.

8. Detecting the presence of a tiny amount of synthetic compounds in any type of oil, including agarwood oil, is as easy as pie with any reported analytical method, including GC-MS.

9. Capturing the best olfactory quality in the distilled oil is a combination of raw material quality, distillation apparatus features and the skill of the operator. So the outcome depends on many permutations and combinations. Yet, no matter how good or bad any of those parameters are controlled, a chemical signature of authentic oil will never be lost in the final oil. So, suppose a distiller or trader tries to blame a counterfeit or adulterated oil on any of those parameters to cover up wrongdoing. In that case, it is impossible to hide the evidence of its criminality.

10: The Chemical fingerprinting of an oil is as substantial as its wood DNA fingerprint if both are derived from the same piece of plant material.
View attachment 51118
How many of you think these perfumes are the same as stated on the labels?

I have always admired inspiring personalities who believe that Allah (Glory be to Him) created everything in precise measure. This belief represents a profound level of faith within our true religion, Islam—to contemplate and reflect upon the greatness of the Creator within ourselves and throughout all His creation.

In light of your topic, I would like to offer a brief insight into the origin of fragrance products. We enjoy beautiful scents, but we must ask: is the product "Single-Note" (Monolithic) or a "Composition/Blend" of various essential oils?

  • If it is a Single-Note product: The seller is ethically and religiously obligated to declare its purity. It must be free from any natural or synthetic additives or dilutions to clear one’s conscience.
  • If it is a Composition or Blend: A professional perfumer may need to add natural extracts or secondary chemical compounds for reasons related to Fragrance Chemistry. These include, but are not limited to:
    • Creating "bridges" and cohesion between materials within the Olfactory Pyramid.
    • Adding fixatives to slow down evaporation and control the rate of diffusion.
    • Reducing skin absorption of the formula; if the skin absorbs the oil too quickly, longevity is compromised.
There are different schools of thought here: those who rely exclusively on natural ingredients, and those who integrate modern fragrance chemistry with nature.

The Professional Dilemma​

In the second scenario (Compositions), the core of the blend might consist of precious, pure natural materials—such as Oud oil, Rose oil, Sandalwood, Ambergris, and Deer Musk. However, the perfumer might face obstacles like "muting" of the scent, weak projection, or poor longevity.

A professional perfumer intervenes to solve these technical issues with acceptable additives that yield positive results. However, when subjected to GC-MS (Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry) analysis, these chemical additives—originally designed as aromatic enhancers or substitutes—will appear.

This leads to a pivotal question: Does this technical intervention constitute a form of deception or fraud? Furthermore, is the perfumer required to disclose their "trade secrets" and the secondary additives that ensured the success and beauty of the blend?

The Ethical and Legal Perspective​

In our Islamic Sharia, a seller must be truthful and disclose any defects in the commodity. Failure to do so results in acquiring "Haram" (illicit) wealth, which carries grave consequences in this life and the Hereafter. We ask Allah for well-being and safety.

I have observed many perfumers highlighting their luxury primary ingredients while only hinting at the "mastery" and "secrets" of their additives without naming them. My view is as follows:

  1. For Single-Note Oils: The GC-MS result must show 100% purity; anything else is a direct contradiction of the product's claim.
  2. For Compositions/Blends: The judgment should differ. The focus should be on the primary elements that form the heart of the blend. Evaluation should be based on the quality of these core ingredients, rather than the secondary auxiliary elements—provided those additives are not prohibited or hazardous materials.
Please excuse my prolixity; I hope my perspective has been clearly conveyed.
 
I have always admired inspiring personalities who believe that Allah (Glory be to Him) created everything in precise measure. This belief represents a profound level of faith within our true religion, Islam—to contemplate and reflect upon the greatness of the Creator within ourselves and throughout all His creation.

In light of your topic, I would like to offer a brief insight into the origin of fragrance products. We enjoy beautiful scents, but we must ask: is the product "Single-Note" (Monolithic) or a "Composition/Blend" of various essential oils?

  • If it is a Single-Note product: The seller is ethically and religiously obligated to declare its purity. It must be free from any natural or synthetic additives or dilutions to clear one’s conscience.
  • If it is a Composition or Blend: A professional perfumer may need to add natural extracts or secondary chemical compounds for reasons related to Fragrance Chemistry. These include, but are not limited to:
    • Creating "bridges" and cohesion between materials within the Olfactory Pyramid.
    • Adding fixatives to slow down evaporation and control the rate of diffusion.
    • Reducing skin absorption of the formula; if the skin absorbs the oil too quickly, longevity is compromised.
There are different schools of thought here: those who rely exclusively on natural ingredients, and those who integrate modern fragrance chemistry with nature.

The Professional Dilemma​

In the second scenario (Compositions), the core of the blend might consist of precious, pure natural materials—such as Oud oil, Rose oil, Sandalwood, Ambergris, and Deer Musk. However, the perfumer might face obstacles like "muting" of the scent, weak projection, or poor longevity.

A professional perfumer intervenes to solve these technical issues with acceptable additives that yield positive results. However, when subjected to GC-MS (Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry) analysis, these chemical additives—originally designed as aromatic enhancers or substitutes—will appear.

This leads to a pivotal question: Does this technical intervention constitute a form of deception or fraud? Furthermore, is the perfumer required to disclose their "trade secrets" and the secondary additives that ensured the success and beauty of the blend?

The Ethical and Legal Perspective​

In our Islamic Sharia, a seller must be truthful and disclose any defects in the commodity. Failure to do so results in acquiring "Haram" (illicit) wealth, which carries grave consequences in this life and the Hereafter. We ask Allah for well-being and safety.

I have observed many perfumers highlighting their luxury primary ingredients while only hinting at the "mastery" and "secrets" of their additives without naming them. My view is as follows:

  1. For Single-Note Oils: The GC-MS result must show 100% purity; anything else is a direct contradiction of the product's claim.
  2. For Compositions/Blends: The judgment should differ. The focus should be on the primary elements that form the heart of the blend. Evaluation should be based on the quality of these core ingredients, rather than the secondary auxiliary elements—provided those additives are not prohibited or hazardous materials.
Please excuse my prolixity; I hope my perspective has been clearly conveyed.
Beautifully written as always brother, To add my two cents:
If a perfumer announces, blatantly and directly, that their compositions are natural, then it is expected that the blend contains 0% synthetics. They dont need to disclose anything in the formula, many people simply mention the major, effective ingredients, and leave out the bridges, or "artistic touches" as some consider them trade secrets, or so minute that they dont need to be mentioned.

The perfumer that uses synthetics to boost, or improve natural materials, is not obligated to reveal exactly what they use, but they're obligated -in my opinion- to announce that there are synthetics present in the formula, only IF they already established themselves as a natural perfumer, or that the specific perfume is completely natural. Because the fact that they used synthetics directly contradicts the fact they called the blend 100% natural, therefore it must be disclosed, since the fact stated before (the 100% natural ingredients claim) directly affects perceived value and price, and what affects perceived value and price must always be disclosed. Eg. if i sell you a car, it is expected to be a functional, working car. If the car has an issue that is out of norm such as severe rust, a flat tire, engine misfiring, then i must disclose it before the sale is finalized, because those issues will directly affect the price and value at the time of purchase, and you might cancel the purchase because of them.

I think everyone agrees that the mere use of synthetics is not a problem in itself, the problem is in honesty, and taking accountability. Nobody calls YSL, or Henry Jacques, or Chanel and Creed scammers or liars for using synthetics in their perfumes, because they never put themselves in a position to be critiqued over that.
 
So far there has been comparison between 100% natural and/or synthetic materials. But what of semi-synthetic or natural isolates? These two classes of materials blurr the lines of 100% natural, there are "perfumers" who use them and consider them 100% natural materials as well while to others they may not be considered 100% natural.
 
So far there has been comparison between 100% natural and/or synthetic materials. But what of semi-synthetic or natural isolates? These two classes of materials blurr the lines of 100% natural, there are "perfumers" who use them and consider them 100% natural materials as well while to others they may not be considered 100% natural.
i've got another one… Some isolates are made just by purifying essential oils further. But some are made by genetically modifying microorganisms to produce specific aroma chemicals. Natural? Not natural? "synthetic"?
 
i've got another one… Some isolates are made just by purifying essential oils further. But some are made by genetically modifying microorganisms to produce specific aroma chemicals. Natural? Not natural? "synthetic"?
Microbial bioprocess products from natural (plant- or animal-based) sources are in the "Biobased" domain, in contrast to petroleum-based synthetic products. In the context of the circular economy, most of us feel comfortable with microbial bioprocess products, as those are cheap yet not synthetic in everyday terms. For example, the citric acid you buy from a so-called "organic product" store is almost always not from any citrus fruit juice extract but from the GM Black Mould strain's fermentation-based industrial production line. We need to be careful about using 100% Organic, 100% natural, biobased, and so on... due to shady business practices in product labelling. Last year, I conducted a survey of natural products available in supermarkets in the Netherlands. I found that most of the product levels are deceptive, at least when it comes to natural ingredient-based products.
A label saying “100% Natural” on an essential oil does not mean the product contains 100% of that particular ingredient; rather, the “100% natural” label also includes any natural ingredients in that bottle of which the business has not disclosed on that label as an excuse for exercising the right of business secret. Saying 100% pure Jojoba oil does not mean it does not contain other cheaper ingredients in the bottle. If you catch them red-handed, they would interpret it as such. In the bottle, there is 100% pure Jojoba oil; there may be other natural ingredients, which are also 100% pure and 100% natural. They just did not mention it as a business secret. So technically, they do not lie.
The core point of my argument is this: Is your labelling designed to deceive the client’s good faith? The insurance company/credit card companies are rather more honest in writing their terms in such lengthy small print that a normal person can not read within five to ten minutes, even with their best effort and are forced to sign the contract. So my basic question was, some of the perfumers' unnecessarily lengthy, super poetic product descriptions are to help understand the product well or to mislead the consumer with an overwhelmingly diluted sea of information in which very basic information is hidden or not mentioned, so that the client loses their gauge of judgement of a particular product either with its competitor or accessing the price tag of the product on offer.
 
So my basic question was, some of the perfumers' unnecessarily lengthy, super poetic product descriptions are to help understand the product well or to mislead the consumer with an overwhelmingly diluted sea of information in which very basic information is hidden or not mentioned, so that the client loses their gauge of judgement of a particular product either with its competitor or accessing the price tag of the product on offer.

Yes this is an exhausting aspect of this whole business 😂

I greatly appreciate the folks who just list the facts simply and separately from the poetic/hype text.
 
i've got another one… Some isolates are made just by purifying essential oils further. But some are made by genetically modifying microorganisms to produce specific aroma chemicals. Natural? Not natural? "synthetic"?
Came back here to share this link https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/#iso:std:iso:9235:ed-3:v1:en
apparently theres an ISO standard on natural perfumery ingredients
From what i understand, bacteria produced aroma chemicals are natural based on the ISO standard.
also check this
"absolute
product obtained by extraction with ethanol from a concrete (3.7), a pomade (3.23), a resinoid (3.27) or a supercritical fluid extract (3.28)"
According to this, if you (for example) tincture some vanilla beans in alcohol, then filter it, and evaporate the alcohol, the result technically isnt an absolute, as the precursor must be a concrete, pomade, resinoid or CO2 extract. Pretty weird i must say.
 
Last edited:
Came back here to share this link https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/#iso:std:iso:9235:ed-3:v1:en
apparently theres an ISO standard on natural perfumery ingredients
From what i understand, bacteria produced aroma chemicals are natural based on the ISO standard.
also check this
"absolute
product obtained by extraction with ethanol from a concrete (3.7), a pomade (3.23), a resinoid (3.27) or a supercritical fluid extract (3.28)"
According to this, if you (for example) tincture some vanilla beans in alcohol, then filter it, and evaporate the alcohol, the result technically isnt an absolute, as the precursor must be a concrete, pomade, resinoid or CO2 extract. Pretty weird i must say.
yes! absolutes are made by a two-stage process starting with a hydrocarbon extraction followed by alcohol extraction and evaporation. Concentrated tinctures should be called folded tinctures or perhaps resinoid and should not be called absolutes.

I think sometimes technical terms for particular extractions reflect decisions made in the moment my people working in the industry and don't always seem logical when viewed from the outside. For example a single step solvent extract can be called either a concrete or a resinoid - generally it's called a concrete when it's from water rich material like fresh flowers, a resinoid when it's from some dry matter. Basically both the same thing in terms of the process itself.

According to Arctander (who ironically said he never wanted his book to be cited as some kind of last word on these things), sometimes an evaporated tincture of a dry material is referred to as "folded tincture" but also as a "resinoid absolute" or "resin absolute", because the term "absolute" is generally understood to refer to alcohol being used in the extraction process. So calling something a resinoid absolute is a shorthand for a "resinoid extracted with alcohol".

I don't think people are deliberately being deceptive but a two-stage absolute produces a smaller yield, more refined and selective for the essential oil portion of whatever's in the plant. The first solvent used is a hydrocarbon, and they are much more selective than alcohol.

When your initial extraction is with alcohol, because it is a much less selective solvent, you get a much higher yield. There are a variety of materials that will dissolve in alcohol but are not soluble in hydrocarbons or oils. Sugars, other carbohydrates, a variety of pigments, etc.
 
Last edited:
Top