Sometimes I closely follow a few interesting topics here solely to learn something new. Unfortunately, I get disappointed almost every occasion. The junk inside of each topic gets heavier as the discussion moves forward, and sometimes even the plot is lost altogether. So, the questions arise: am I really educating myself by spending time here, or is a misconception even unconsciously injected into my brain? Well, I am not criticising Ouddict for its openness to accommodate opinions from every corner. It is even the opposite; I could not even stand reading some other blogs outside this forum for the stuff described on those online boards. The main concern for me is whether open, unmoderated postings lean more toward fruitful education or can spread misconceptions, fantasies, or even outright lies.
View attachment 51116
I know this is not a scientific journal, and there is no liability to stick only to the facts. Fiction is also an essential part of humankind's progress. Otherwise, we would not pay to go to the theatre. Yet, we watch that film knowing each character is nothing but fiction. So, when the actor or actress behaves differently in real life than in the film, it does not hurt us. But in the case of perfume or essential oil description, when the facts, fiction, and lies take a single trajectory into a space defying all gravity of reality, and for that 4D fictitious journey, the storyteller charges the customers whatever they like; there is no fixed price like a theatre ticket. What is even worse is that customers are given the impression they will watch a documentary produced by the Attenborough team. Yes, there is always a place for imagination and extrapolation based on facts and experience, but when imagination and fiction blur and gradually lead customers into a dark chamber filled with lies and deception, it suffocates me. Weeks before, when I was in Paris and walking through a street in the perfumery district, I stepped into a shop that was decorated in such a way that, inside, it felt like a spaceship film set, another world. When I smelled a few Oudh perfumes from that outlet, they were as ordinary as anything. Yet the saleswomen's lies and deception were meant to cover up the product's flaws. It gave me such a distaste for that elite work of light and decoration; I quickly walked off. So, what is the way forward not to fall into the trap of lies that are polished with imagination and fiction?
There is no alternative to the pure work of science. When I started my journey to verify the authenticity of agarwood oil and implement measures to protect the welfare of both honest entrepreneurs and customers, I expected a warm welcome from both sides. But reality is harsh. Customers are more inclined to fiction than to the unpolished truth. If I had expected support, by now so many nice facts would have been revealed, even outbidding some of the fictions circulating in the market now. But never mind, moving forward is the only solution for the time being. Yet, I can leave here some of my imagination, based on scientific facts, to draw a line between fiction and lies alike. If it does help with your purchase decision for your next oil, then I would say spending some of my time on this journey is not totally wasted, and your valuable time reading this nonsense. Here are some of my hypotheses or imagination on oil characteristics, whatever you prefer to call it:
1. All types of natural oils have a common characteristic.
2. All species of agarwood oil have a typical character. The oil of each agarwood species has its own chemical fingerprint, regardless of the region where it is grown. Each agarwood species may have different varieties; each variety shows its own regional chemical fingerprint captured in the oil. For each variety or species, the wild and various artificial methods impart their own signature to the developed agarwood character and, hence, to the final oil.
3. If one adds another type of oil to agarwood oil, the common characteristic of agarwood oil becomes distorted. Without GC-MS testing, it is not possible to know what kind of other natural product is added, but you will surely know either by sniffing or spectroscopic fingerprinting.
4. It does not matter what type of distillation method one uses; a common chemical fingerprint of agarwood oil (such as A. A. crassna) will not be lost.
5. It does not matter if one uses a very low-quality or double super quality wood of a specific species; a common chemical fingerprint of that species will always remain in the oil.
6. If the same distillation pot is used to distil a different quality of the same agarwood species for a period of time without a complete wash or cleaning of the vessel, there will be a distinct fingerprint character of the pot remaining in each oil. In other words, different distillation pots put their signature on their oil. I caught a few distillers telling lies as if someone else's oil was their own, because I already recognised the fingerprint of their pot in some of their previous oil. I have not scientifically proven this in any peer-reviewed paper, but I am happy to put in my two cents on the outcome of this bet.
7. A chemical fingerprint and the olfactory fingerprint are not the same thing to confuse. All the features I mentioned above relate to the chemical fingerprint. GC-MS is not sufficient to capture the olfactory characteristics of each oil, but it is effective at detecting chemical fingerprints. So, with GC-MS, it is not easy to determine the olfactory quality of an oil, but it is easy to detect even a drop of non-agarwood oil adulteration in one tula.
8. Detecting the presence of a tiny amount of synthetic compounds in any type of oil, including agarwood oil, is as easy as pie with any reported analytical method, including GC-MS.
9. Capturing the best olfactory quality in the distilled oil is a combination of raw material quality, distillation apparatus features and the skill of the operator. So the outcome depends on many permutations and combinations. Yet, no matter how good or bad any of those parameters are controlled, a chemical signature of authentic oil will never be lost in the final oil. So, suppose a distiller or trader tries to blame a counterfeit or adulterated oil on any of those parameters to cover up wrongdoing. In that case, it is impossible to hide the evidence of its criminality.
10: The Chemical fingerprinting of an oil is as substantial as its wood DNA fingerprint if both are derived from the same piece of plant material.
View attachment 51118
How many of you think these perfumes are the same as stated on the labels?