A question on the fundamental principles of perfumery, I would like to know the name of the person who wrote these down, if not the person, then the culture, era and so on......
It doesn’t even have to go that deep. Basic principles are for example understanding what are top, heart & base notes. You can on the one hand tell by the longevity of the raw material. Then you look at each individual ingredient & categorize their scent profile. This helps seeing similarities with other ingredients & deepen your understanding of them. You will know what works well with what.
Regarding methods there are multiple renowned ones, like the one from Guerlain, but to each their own, you have to view the raw materials individually & see what works best for them.
But if you don‘t care about how much of what you are putting in, you are risking that some notes won‘t be noticeable at all, while others are dominating everything else, which is a total waste of the other materials & their nuances to a blend. This is basically wasted potential. If you put in a drop of bergamot next to a gram of oud & deer musk, then good luck with detecting bergamot throughout the wear at all. Additionally, if notes don’t match at all, it can smell really inharmonious & potentially even off putting. Like what was the point in putting in so many ingredients in a blend when all you’re smelling is a single one or it smells like an annoying mess with no clear direction.

You can draw parallels to cooking here as well. Would you rather combine Nutella with onion & salt, or simply put some it on some bread ? The latter, in my opinion, is the better option. A sweet & chocolatey cream on bread is more harmonious & delicate to me than sweet chocolate cream with salt & onions. Would you rather combine banana with melted chocolate or blue cheese & garlic ? Of course there are different cultures & tastes, it is possible that someone thinks Nutella with onions or banana with garlic is better, but come on now lol. Another one : Steak with fries or steak with peanut butter, lemon & soy sauce ? You get what I’m saying right ? The different taste categories are sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami. Every chef knows that it is important to keep a good balance between them. A tea shouldn’t be brewed for too long, as it will become too bitter. You don‘t put a kilo of salt on 100grams of chicken. A steak shouldn‘t be cooked for too long or little. Combining the most random & different ingredients together without caring about proportions & cooking time of each may be creative, but only in the rarest cases it will turn out well & harmonious. Or do you think raw garlic with cow milk, chocolate & chips is a nice, harmonious & professional dish ?
There are spices with scoville levels so high, that even adding a tiny amount of them will destroy & overshadow a complex recipe. You won‘t taste any of the other precious ingredients, as the heat of the spice will dominate & ruin your tongue & stomach with tears in your eyes.

It’s the same with blending with oud, florals & animalics.
This is why you at least need some basic understanding of every ingredient you’re working with. The higher ones understanding & experience of them is, the higher their standards will be.

But again, it‘s just personal preference. Some like it more methodic, harmonious & elegant, perfectly structured, with every ingredient getting showcased enough & providing maximum complexity, while others like brute force, with one note dominating all the others, edgy, raw, chaotic & so on. To each their own.
I prefer people who understand raw materials & know how to cook. I love harmonious complexity. Some of my favorites in artisanal perfumery would be Mellifluence, Agar Aura & House of Heartistry.. They understand & showcase their materials really well, everything smells harmonious, well structured & calculated, they apply basic perfumery principals & so on. Sometimes Elixir Attar & Teone Reinthal also fit right up my alley. EO & ALD also in rare cases. N.O.A.M also mastered his stuff. Also Ahom World when it comes to traditional oriental perfumery, man that guys a stud. There are actually so many artisanal perfumers that are skilled I‘m realizing while writing this lol
 
But again, it‘s just personal preference. Some like it more methodic, harmonious & elegant, perfectly structured, with every ingredient getting showcased enough & providing maximum complexity, while others like brute force, with one note dominating all the others, edgy, raw, chaotic & so on. To each their own.
I prefer people who understand raw materials & know how to cook. I love harmonious complexity. Some of my favorites in artisanal perfumery would be Mellifluence, Agar Aura & House of Heartistry.. They understand & showcase their materials really well, everything smells harmonious, well structured & calculated, they apply basic perfumery principals & so on. Sometimes Elixir Attar & Teone Reinthal also fit right up my alley. EO & ALD also in rare cases. N.O.A.M also mastered his stuff. Also Ahom World when it comes to traditional oriental perfumery, man that guys a stud. There are actually so many artisanal perfumers that are skilled I‘m realizing while writing this lol
Agree and I want to add just a few words to this. What people like the OP often forget is the overall scent. Skilled, trained, following rules etc., if the scent in the end isn't good for my nose, I don't buy it. It doesn't matter who produced it. And in the opposite is the same. If the so called perfumer is having success with this kind of “haphazardly throwing together blends in the new style of “bad perfumery is actually good perfumery””, congratulations from my side.
At this point I think everyone should understand that art especially perfume is not something that has to follow some basic rules, what works with what etc., if it matters to you just skip them. But using it as a critic point in order to make the work obsolete is not fair. Should negative reviews exist? Yes. Should you be able to criticise his work? Yes.
In the end his art didn't work for you but for others it does.
 
Agree and I want to add just a few words to this. What people like the OP often forget is the overall scent. Skilled, trained, following rules etc., if the scent in the end isn't good for my nose, I don't buy it. It doesn't matter who produced it. And in the opposite is the same. If the so called perfumer is having success with this kind of “haphazardly throwing together blends in the new style of “bad perfumery is actually good perfumery””, congratulations from my side.
At this point I think everyone should understand that art especially perfume is not something that has to follow some basic rules, what works with what etc., if it matters to you just skip them. But using it as a critic point in order to make the work obsolete is not fair. Should negative reviews exist? Yes. Should you be able to criticise his work? Yes.
In the end his art didn't work for you but for others it does.
Well said.
 
The OP is entitled to his views as he is a customer and others are entitled to respond to the review, but I don't understand the general direction of this post. Remember, context is everything and perhaps you don't see it, but to me (and probably others) it would seem that your remarks about the esoteric perfumer, bad perfumery and mud smelling good etc will be seen in the light of Elkhaldi Perfumes which unless you have a specific review about their products seems like you are placing them in that description which is quite flippant and can be devastating for someone who has spent their time and money only to be associated with a post like this. It is unfair. And if you do have their perfumes, then such sweeping comments belong in a separate review, because there will be readers who assume - as your comments are posted on this review thread - that you are talking about Elkhaldi Perfumes amongst others. Can you make it clear what you are referring to? Also, your comments seem to imply that other reviews might not be honest or somehow questionable?

On another note, I know that Maher is a new perfumer who has spared no expense with his creations and used the finest raw materials from other established artisans, not limited to Al Hashimi. He could have just gone the route as some other perfumers and used the cheapest generic materials but he chose not to. He is still learning and I have smelled many of his creations many which hit the mark for me and some that don't, but that is a personal and subjective opinion and others have different tastes. This is what people also need to understand, that reviews are fine, but they are the product of a personal preference the majority of the time and others may differ.

His debut Izzudeen attar is hands-down the best citrus floral I have ever smelled and I actually bought a bottle of it. I seldom ever buy bottles of anything from any vendor as I am perma-broke investing in my own business ventures, so this is an indication of the impact it had on me - for perspective, the last attar I purchased prior to that was @Al Shareef Oudh magnificent Ghalliyah Attar back in 2017.

Somewhat off topic -- and possibly a relief -- have you ever tried @Al Shareef Oudh's Al Ghaliyah II or Al Bayt Al Ateeq II? I've heard wonderful things about the original Ghaliyah Attar you have, and was wondering how it compares with these. I have Al Bayt Al Ateeq II and it's out-of-this-world fantastic. I was wondering whether -- owning this -- there's any reason to buy the Ghaliyah. Obviously it's different but they're both oudh, musk, ambergris and rose. And I refuse to believe anything could top Al Bayt.
 
I have a sample bottle of both Al GhaliyahII and Al Bayt and they are both simula and very different in scent profile to me. Grab a sample and see.
It's funny, but I have quite a few Al Shareef samples. I bought them early on. I'm going to have to take a look.

P.S. I love the way you said this. Totally get it: "they are both simula and very different in scent profile to me."
 
Look at Areej, people love his bold and old style in the first collections and are complaining now because his blends are too french and well blended.
Lol. I’m one of those who started collecting his perfumes until my wallet ran dry so I don’t buy sets anymore.

I don’t have the original Ottoman Empire but I have all of its other versions, down to the most recent release. If I read it correctly somewhere, he does have a formula for it but ingredients come from different sources and batches, resulting in variances. So, not a reformulation issue? I loved them all anyway, even the “weaker” and newer ones so there.
 
Lol. I’m one of those who started collecting his perfumes until my wallet ran dry so I don’t buy sets anymore.

I don’t have the original Ottoman Empire but I have all of its other versions, down to the most recent release. If I read it correctly somewhere, he does have a formula for it but ingredients come from different sources and batches, resulting in variances. So, not a reformulation issue? I loved them all anyway, even the “weaker” and newer ones so there.
It's nice seeing you here! Hope you comment more often 🙂
 
It's nice seeing you here! Hope you comment more often 🙂
Hello, SophMarie.

I hardly post messages because my fragrance vocabulary re oil and attar/mukhallat is severely limited to just “oohs” and “ahhs”. But, oftentimes, I hit Like for comments that my simple mind can grasp. Lol.

I am still crossing over, from alcohol-containing perfumes to those without alcohol. I still have a lot of the former while I’m slowly developing some sort of evaluation sentences/phrases in my mind about the latter:
“I like this.”
“I love that.”
“I like this more than that.”
“Oh, my.”
“Eww.”

When I’m finally able to make more sense of my system of evaluation, I’ll say more than just oohs and ahhs.

Now, I’ve been waiting for your reviews of your Teone Reinthal goodies. Hurry up and give me some ideas!
 
Hello, SophMarie.

I hardly post messages because my fragrance vocabulary re oil and attar/mukhallat is severely limited to just “oohs” and “ahhs”. But, oftentimes, I hit Like for comments that my simple mind can grasp. Lol.

I am still crossing over, from alcohol-containing perfumes to those without alcohol. I still have a lot of the former while I’m slowly developing some sort of evaluation sentences/phrases in my mind about the latter:
“I like this.”
“I love that.”
“I like this more than that.”
“Oh, my.”
“Eww.”

When I’m finally able to make more sense of my system of evaluation, I’ll say more than just oohs and ahhs.

Now, I’ve been waiting for your reviews of your Teone Reinthal goodies. Hurry up and give me some ideas!
Haven’t you noticed noticed my comments are mostly “ooh”, “aah”, and gorgeous”? 😁 I don’t have the reviewer vocabulary some of the others do 😉
 
Somewhat off topic -- and possibly a relief -- have you ever tried @Al Shareef Oudh's Al Ghaliyah II or Al Bayt Al Ateeq II? I've heard wonderful things about the original Ghaliyah Attar you have, and was wondering how it compares with these. I have Al Bayt Al Ateeq II and it's out-of-this-world fantastic. I was wondering whether -- owning this -- there's any reason to buy the Ghaliyah. Obviously it's different but they're both oudh, musk, ambergris and rose. And I refuse to believe anything could top Al Bayt.
It's worth at least sampling Al Ghaliyah II. It's not very similar to ABAAII.
 
Fascinating discussion on artisanal perfumery… when someone buys perfume of a niche / artisanal maker, before making the decision to buy & given that you know so little about the perfumer or his work, if new, what triggers you to make a purchase? If it is based on the ingredients the parfum consists of….Is it the use of precious, rare & costly ingredients? What if someone constructs a parfum based on indigenous botanies (even developing custom animalics), his own choice of Oud (not necessarily the most wildest)? And hence, not over the top pricing. But a parfum that’s a design of a designer, a creative individual, following basic principles. I do think exciting & interesting work is possible with irregular, natural ingredients, if you know how to design it.
If you’re given the best of ingredients, the musks, damascenas, aged, rarest Ouds, white ambergris & all the known ingredients - the usual suspects, you’re supposed to get something probably you already know how it could smell, in your mind. But if a designer decides to incorporate some degree of ingenuity in his creation (and even add in well known ingredients), the designer knows what he’s doing, the olfaction he’s aiming for, the story he has built, could that be interesting for you?
If I was such a perfumer, I’d be looking for connoisseurs interested in (calculated) adventure than ones aiming for least risk, its artisanal design of perfumes we’re talking about. Must carry signature of the perfumer and his location, and that’s what designer product & craftsmanship are.
 
Last edited:
Fascinating discussion on artisanal perfumery… when someone buys perfume of a niche / artisanal maker, before making the decision to buy & given that you know so little about the perfumer or his work, if new, what triggers you to make a purchase? If it is based on the ingredients the parfum consists of….Is it the use of precious, rare & costly ingredients? What if someone constructs a parfum based on indigenous botanies (even developing custom animalics), his own choice of Oud (not necessarily the most wildest)? And hence, not over the top pricing. But a parfum that’s a design of a designer, a creative individual, following basic principles. I do think exciting & interesting work is possible with irregular, natural ingredients, if you know how to design it.
If you’re given the best of ingredients, the musks, damascenas, aged, rarest Ouds, white ambergris & all the known ingredients - the usual suspects, you’re supposed to get something probably you already know how it could smell, in your mind. But if a designer decides to incorporate some degree of ingenuity in his creation (and even add in well known ingredients), the designer knows what he’s doing, the olfaction he’s aiming for, the story he has built, could that be interesting for you?
If I was such a perfumer, I’d be looking for connoisseurs interested in (calculated) adventure than ones aiming for least risk, its artisanal design of perfumes we’re talking about. Must carry signature of the perfumer and his location, and that’s what designer product & craftsmanship are.

@Kalni Oud , I grew up with parents and sister who are perfume lovers. Early on, I was exposed to French and to Italian perfumes that heavily influenced my evolution as a perfume lover. For four decades, for me, those were at the apex of perfumery. It helps, too, that I have lived in cities where perfume retail stores are aplenty. Nothing beats sampling perfumes first before buying them.

Then, online shopping happened. There were no samples to test or even to buy in the beginning. So I took a chance and blind bought some Ensar Oud, Areej Le Dore, and Bortnikoff oils and perfumes. Wow, theirs was/is an entirely different world of perfumes! I was hooked. It would be honest to declare, though, that a few of their products did not make it to my favorites list.

That said, I blind buy. But, I get seriously influenced by reviews, too. I, fortunately, am beginning to develop my own taste for certain artisans and their products so I have no problem ordering again from those whom I’ve bought before and liked/loved.

I hope I answered your queries, even in part.
 
Last edited:
@Kalni Oud , I grew up with parents and sister who are perfume lovers. Early on, I was exposed to French and to Italian perfumes that heavily influenced my evolution as a perfume lover. For four decades, for me, those were at the apex of perfumery. It helps, too, that I have lived in cities where perfume retail stores are aplenty. Nothing beats sampling perfumes first before buying them.

Then, online shopping happened. There were no samples to test or even to buy in the beginning. So I took a chance and blind bought some Ensar Oud, Areej Le Dore, and Bortnikoff oils and perfumes. Wow, theirs was/is an entirely different world of perfumes! I was hooked. It would be honest to declare, though, that a few of their products did not make it to my favorites list.

That said, I blind buy. But, I get seriously influenced by reviews, too. I, fortunately, am beginning to develop my own taste for certain artisans and their products so I have no problem ordering again from those whom I’ve bought before and liked/loved.

I hope I answered your queries, even in part.
I blind buy a lot, too. I am also frequently influenced by the buyers' reviews. Most of the time, I end up liking it, or even loving it, and have never returned a single one.
 
@Kalni Oud , I grew up with parents and sister who are perfume lovers. Early on, I was exposed to French and to Italian perfumes that heavily influenced my evolution as a perfume lover. For four decades, for me, those were at the apex of perfumery. It helps, too, that I have lived in cities where perfume retail stores are aplenty. Nothing beats sampling perfumes first before buying them.

Then, online shopping happened. There were no samples to test or even to buy in the beginning. So I took a chance and blind bought some Ensar Oud, Areej Le Dore, and Bortnikoff oils and perfumes. Wow, theirs was/is an entirely different world of perfumes! I was hooked. It would be honest to declare, though, that a few of their products did not make it to my favorites list.

That said, I blind buy. But, I get seriously influenced by reviews, too. I, fortunately, am beginning to develop my own taste for certain artisans and their products so I have no problem ordering again from those whom I’ve bought before and liked/loved.

I hope I answered your queries, even in part.
@ManilaDawn, what are some of the best Bortnikoff's? Luckyscent is having a 10%, free shipping deal today and I need some informed recs!
 
@ManilaDawn, what are some of the best Bortnikoff's? Luckyscent is having a 10%, free shipping deal today and I need some informed recs!
Bortnikoff does a buy 2 and get 1 free perfume deals or buy 1 and get a travel size for free and some other deals every while 😉 no rush

I can recommend the classics: oud monarch (gourmand oud), tabac dore, lao oud (barny oud) and basically all his floral oud perfumes are good. He knows how to do a floral oud.
I didnt try any of his newer collections
 
Bortnikoff does a buy 2 and get 1 free perfume deals or buy 1 and get a travel size for free and some other deals every while 😉 no rush

I can recommend the classics: oud monarch (gourmand oud), tabac dore, lao oud (barny oud) and basically all his floral oud perfumes are good. He knows how to do a floral oud.
I didnt try any of his newer collections
Then I will wait! I'd rather do the buy 2 get 1 free. lol
 
@ManilaDawn, what are some of the best Bortnikoff's? Luckyscent is having a 10%, free shipping deal today and I need some informed recs!
Oh, I’m humbled. I’m not in any way a subject matter expert re Bortnikoff, as I have 3 full bottles of his - Musk Khabib (1st issue), Oud Monarch (1st issue), and Oud Maximus. And some samplers most of which are still unopened. That said, I can vouch for the 3 that I use every now and then.

Oud Maximus is a wonderful intro to his Oud perfumes. It has a very pleasant Oud scent with just a tinge of animalic. It has a cool component (clove?) that I feel makes it wearable during the warm seasons.

Oud Monarch, to me, is similar to Oud Maximus but sweeter. No detectable animalic in this one. One can spray these two Oud perfumes side-by-side and the difference will be obvious. Both are beautiful Oud perfumes … in a western kind of way.

Musk Khabib is a gorgeous powdery musk perfume that has citrusy and floral components. It’s so well-blended that it smells like a wall of scents surrounding you and, one by one, the flowers come forward. Very appealing to my female cousins.

Vetiver Nocturne? I feel that vetiver here is the glue that stays in the background but weaves all the spectacular floral components together. I only have a sampler of the 1st issue so I cannot say the same for the reissues.

I dare say Bortnikoff makes good use of ouds and musks in his perfumes … but his mastery truly is with citrus and florals.
 
Back
Top