Oh, I’m humbled. I’m not in any way a subject matter expert re Bortnikoff, as I have 3 full bottles of his - Musk Khabib (1st issue), Oud Monarch (1st issue), and Oud Maximus. And some samplers most of which are still unopened. That said, I can vouch for the 3 that I use every now and then.
Oud Maximus is a wonderful intro to his Oud perfumes. It has a very pleasant Oud scent with just a tinge of animalic. It has a cool component (clove?) that I feel makes it wearable during the warm seasons.
Oud Monarch, to me, is similar to Oud Maximus but sweeter. No detectable animalic in this one. One can spray these two Oud perfumes side-by-side and the difference will be obvious. Both are beautiful Oud perfumes … in a western kind of way.
Musk Khabib is a gorgeous powdery musk perfume that has citrusy and floral components. It’s so well-blended that it smells like a wall of scents surrounding you and, one by one, the flowers come forward. Very appealing to my female cousins.
Vetiver Nocturne? I feel that vetiver here is the glue that stays in the background but weaves all the spectacular floral components together. I only have a sampler of the 1st issue so I cannot say the same for the reissues.
I dare say Bortnikoff makes good use of ouds and musks in his perfumes … but his mastery truly is with citrus and florals.