Oudamberlove
Member
Homemade Vietnamese Stick
I used charcoal in the recipe,
now it has similarities to Seijudo’s sticks.
I used charcoal in the recipe,
now it has similarities to Seijudo’s sticks.
Labor of LoveMy Kyara sticks
View attachment 13401


random comment
For all of those from amongst us who have succeed in making decent sticks, did you realise where the incense sticks from the big famous japanese houses really stand and how much of it is their successful marketing to make your perceive quality? the more of the boutique sticks i smell by others and myself, i become more and more critical of those houses.
I find it even more interesting that people continue to regurgitate the same marketing material, as though they havent learnt nothing about smelling over the many years, the power of words...
Finding a connoisseur level stick from the current batches available at the big Japanese incense houses is a daunting task. Even the older batches, you’ll get some good stuff and some not so.
For the most part, I find sticks to be like Mukhallats and Oud Oils. The blended ones can be exquisite to poor, depending on the quality of the ingredients and the composition, and the sticks made from agarwood alone, can carry a complex and wonderful profile, as if it were a composition, but only to the extent of the quality of the agarwood used, and how the stick was formed also.
Yes I have to agree. I definitely feel that they arent that great in blending or as you say the mukhallat genre.Finding a connoisseur level stick from the current batches available at the big Japanese incense houses is a daunting task. Even the older batches, you’ll get some good stuff and some not so.
For the most part, I find sticks to be like Mukhallats and Oud Oils. The blended ones can be exquisite to poor, depending on the quality of the ingredients and the composition, and the sticks made from agarwood alone, can carry a complex and wonderful profile, as if it were a composition, but only to the extent of the quality of the agarwood used, and how the stick was formed also.
IMO Kohgen Kyara, Seijudo Kyara Enju, Baieido Kyara Kokoh, and in a mukhallat way Shoyeido Translucent Path.What are considered to be the top most end sticks from the major Japanese houses?
Yes I have to agree. I definitely feel that they arent that great in blending or as you say the mukhallat genre.
My expectation is based a bit on the older stuff when it comes to their single origin oudhs as well. I find that i can smell way too much binder and combustion material in them.
