how does manzar oud compare to others here?
I tended to find that they were very barn heavy, which dominated the entire wear. Each did have it's own scent profile but to me it seemed very lightly layered under the barny notes, until that was all that was left. I don't mind a little bit of barn were it doesn't dominate or it disappears as it dries down, but I found that this was not these oils for me. Obviously this is my opinion and my novice nose; I think there are others here who have tried his stuff and could probably comment better about his oils; but I don't think these are for me and am looking to get de-stash these once I am able to; so I can get some other oils I'd prefer.
 
I tended to find that they were very barn heavy, which dominated the entire wear. Each did have it's own scent profile but to me it seemed very lightly layered under the barny notes, until that was all that was left. I don't mind a little bit of barn were it doesn't dominate or it disappears as it dries down, but I found that this was not these oils for me. Obviously this is my opinion and my novice nose; I think there are others here who have tried his stuff and could probably comment better about his oils; but I don't think these are for me and am looking to get de-stash these once I am able to; so I can get some other oils I'd prefer.
I can't comment on these oils in particular but I've definitely seen a certain type of fermentation that behaves just like you describe, a whole suite of accessory notes that outperform the real oud notes themselves. I've experienced this in very expensive SQ oils and really entry-levelAl Haramain and Ajmal oils so I can't help but imagine it's largely matter of the traditional processing for the Middle Eastern market as opposed to the quality of the wood itself. Like you I find that very distracting and there's only certain occasions where I am willing to have that lingering heaviness on my clothes and skin.

it's interesting because a while back someone who I think was a relative novice and who had only experienced clean distillations from very carefully soaked wood with no rot, and the first traditional fermented distillations they ever smelled were some pricey SQ oils from a reliable source as far as those things go. To this person they all seemed contaminated and poorly made because those fermentation notes are completely absent in the clean distillations. It's something worth thinking about
 
I can't comment on these oils in particular but I've definitely seen a certain type of fermentation that behaves just like you describe, a whole suite of accessory notes that outperform the real oud notes themselves. I've experienced this in very expensive SQ oils and really entry-levelAl Haramain and Ajmal oils so I can't help but imagine it's largely matter of the traditional processing for the Middle Eastern market as opposed to the quality of the wood itself. Like you I find that very distracting and there's only certain occasions where I am willing to have that lingering heaviness on my clothes and skin
Exactly! I certainly have to be in the right mood to wear them, its taken me a long time to go through the oils I think there is still one I haven't worn, but can tell from the bottle it will be barn heavy. I certainly feel it is down to the processing, and like you say using traditional methods rather than the woods. But I have also learned more about what I like; more depth and interest as the wearing of the oil progresses just cleaner; and what to look for in artisans descriptions for things I won't like too.
 
I have a sokkat order arriving tomorrow, maroke 2 tola, bought the last bottle (edit: looks like they've found more, lol). A blind buy, but at worst it should be a good cheap blending source I won't fear to use, and some other of their oils that sounded intriguing. Not artisinal by any means but generally has been of a reasonable quality and not questionable authenticity like many other random non site vendors, and they ship silly fast, door to door in under a week. As I've dialed in my tastes more, these other ones will hopefully fill a void for certain scents, though ME reviews seems to either be just all glowing by culture or google translate mangles them, more details would have been useful.

Had a bit of a sticker shock on tariffs this time though, def seems like some new tariff levels at play now to the US.
 
Last edited:
Finally have another bit of @mesOUD 's recent sandalwood oil (Kabini) on the way and a sample of his recent agarwood distillation! I was concerned I was going to miss out on that sandalwood after the last sample didn't make it; this is one I'm particularly interested in for a couple of reasons. 🙂

I've been a bit out of it as far as exploring my collection lately, too many distractions in my life, but I'm looking forward to studying these.
 
Finally have another bit of @mesOUD 's recent sandalwood oil (Kabini) on the way and a sample of his recent agarwood distillation! I was concerned I was going to miss out on that sandalwood, that's one I'm particularly interested in for a couple of reasons. 🙂
Yes!
 
Received these @Habz786 beauties today!
[Ouddict.com] The Anticipation Thread - Share Your 'inbound's!
 
Apparently its spending season because i also have a whole lot of decants & samples coming in. 3 Rivendare samples and 3 Wasif Reza samples, both highly acclaimed brands with limited batch releases ive been very curious about; as well as a couple handfuls of Teone Reinthal decants, including some or her newest releases which debuted this week.
 
I’m awaiting samples of Hayati and Pleasure Pavilion from Amphora Exotica and a sample pack from Faizal Privee. I’ve been looking for a rose dominant fragrance now that I don’t have any in my collection.
 
Kangiiten just had a restock today for members and I grabbed a handful of shiny trinkets. Mostly a couple woods and perfumes.

5g wild Japanese Tani Agarwood
0.5g wild Cambodia orchid formation
3g wild Tarakan bead spinning scraps.
0.64g wild sinking Manaka piece sourced from Japan
2 new perfumes made by Kyarazen, one boasting an impressive 50% oil content.
 
Kangiiten just had a restock today for members and I grabbed a handful of shiny trinkets. Mostly a couple woods and perfumes.

5g wild Japanese Tani Agarwood
0.5g wild Cambodia orchid formation
3g wild Tarakan bead spinning scraps.
0.64g wild sinking Manaka piece sourced from Japan
2 new perfumes made by Kyarazen, one boasting an impressive 50% oil content.
Damn! So it was you that grabbed that sinking Manaka chip! I couldn't be bothered staying up to midnight last night but if I had, I definitely would have been going for that. Probably one of those Hainan chips as well. At least it's gone to an Ouddict member. Keen to know your thoughts on it once you try it.
I got 5g Wild Japanese Tani agarwood
0.5g wild Cambodia orchid formation (particularly excited for this)
5g Golden Triangle powder
Dreams of Golden Triangle incense
Dreams of Black meat Mysore
There were a couple of other new incense releases as well that I'll get sometime in the future. Overall a very good drop.
 
Haha yes it was me. Thankfully it’s 10:00am where I am so it’s easy to be up for it. This was a very nice drop. The curation is amazing and the Kyarazen perfumes are such a hidden gem. He could charge sooo much more if he wanted to. The quality of them is incredible.

Will def share thoughts on the Manaka chip. I am really curious about the Golden Triangle powder you picked up, almost got it.
 
Top