rOudOlf
Oud Fan
The opening notes of Malay Ultime may be the best notes I’ve smelled. So piercing and addicting.I preffer Malay Ultime over Oud royale, more refined and complex aroma!
The opening notes of Malay Ultime may be the best notes I’ve smelled. So piercing and addicting.I preffer Malay Ultime over Oud royale, more refined and complex aroma!
The opening notes of Malay Ultime may be the best notes I’ve smelled. So piercing and addicting.
it almost smelled to me like they (royale and malay ultime) might've been mixed from similar stock - one scenario that occurred to me was both contain some percentage of the same oil but have been combined with other ouds to achieve different ends by whoever was putting these things together for the SQThe opening notes of Malay Ultime may be the best notes I’ve smelled. So piercing and addicting.
That being said it’s overhyped by the fact it was the first “SQ” oil. Other SQ oils share many same facets of this oil for a way better bang for your buck.
it almost smelled to me like they (royale and malay ultime) might've been mixed from similar stock - one scenario that occurred to me was both contain some percentage of the same oil but have been combined with other ouds to achieve different ends by whoever was putting these things together for the SQ
It's what I would be doing if I had the resources!Large volume high quality distillations, no shortage of money! Then blending with different reigons to achieve various aromas maybe 😁
My personal approach with any oil is that the nose doesn’t lie. I am skeptical of a lot of the SQ oils that pop up, but I still try them and determine whether the scent/longevity/quality/etc. lines up with the price. If I like the oil and the price is right, it doesn’t matter too much to me if it’s a true SQ or not.Many of the SQ labeled- oils in the GCC are actually rip-offs and don't relate to SQ actual stuff in any way. I ran into a few people who bought some of SQ real gold plated- oud boxes, with all the blends and oud oils inside them, for easy money and sold them for reasonable prices to some of the most prominent oud vendors in Saudi Arabia, and they sold them for astronomical prices (literally). I'm talking about a %5000 marginal profits here, if you see what I mean.
So when you are asking is this oil worth this much money or not, it's a question whether you are sincere enough to buy a historical antique in liquid form. It may or may not be your cup of tea. What some oud vendors are saying when offering their top of the line- oud oils for a very steep price is that once the oil is sold the vendor will never find anything like it in the future, and thus a super nova- price tag is stuck on it. Funny enough, many of the now sold out- oils have been succeeded by oils of the same caliber or even superior to them. The prices, though, are out of a common man's (me intended) reach.
Ive never understood the hype around Oud Royale, its honestly to me just a good oil which has been hyped to the moon and back as being some kind of holy grail, when IMO its not. There are so many EO oils which are way better and of course others. The association with spending lots, i feel tricks the mind into believing an oil is better than it actually is thus justifying its cost. No doubt more expensive oils can be amazing and you can smell the difference, however the question is does the difference in price reflect that?
PS im not knocking any vendor @Ouddict knows my views on Oud Royale from years ago. Its on par with oils like super kalimantan ateeq or any other very good aged oil.
It is most difficult to rewire and reeducate oneself from initial learnings. Whether that is a toddlers incorrect foot placement as their first steps, or a budding artist handling of the brush. It really takes a high level of self accountability and honesty to say 'ah I was wrong'.That's because you have this broad experience and understand how it fits into the context of oud overall. Most folks even avid collectors will take a very long time to develop that understanding just because you can't smell things in a hurry.
i'm pretty sure that at the time good maroke of this type was a familiar type of material for experienced folks in the Middle East, but to the United States(?) / western English language online shopping crowd this was a first experience with authentic high-quality Maroke, and that gets carried forward without really taking the larger context into account, which is understandable for somebody who's cutting their teeth on something like this.
it's kind of like the old Thaqueel or Kalakassi - seemed outrageous at the time, basically legendary status until the community had a chance to experience more materials over the decades and understand how it fit in to the bigger picture.
It is most difficult to rewire and reeducate oneself from initial learnings. Whether that is a toddlers incorrect foot placement as their first steps, or a budding artist handling of the brush. It really takes a high level of self accountability and honesty to say 'ah I was wrong'.
Unfortunately for the online Oudh shopping western english speaking community those initial learnings were for the most part just stories. For many that forms the footing of their Oudh experience. Unless the individual has what it takes no one can correct their erroneous initial learnings.
In the story of Romeo and Juliet or Layla and Majnoon, they say that when Layla ended up marrying someone else, Majnoon was devastated. The governor was a person of meticulous standards and everything in his city was kept at a high standard. He would send quality inspectors to check all his departments to ensure all services to his people were at the best they could be.
One day the health inspector was doing his visit to the mental asylum and asked the resident doctor to show him around. The first room he entered upon there was a unkept man and like a record on repeat he was languishing "oh Layla how I miss you, oh Layla how I desire your company". So the inspector asks the resident doctor, 'What happened to him' the doctor responded 'he loved a girl named Layla and she married someone else, and he has lost his mind over her'. The inspector took some notes and was affected by the situation of the young man.
After inspecting some other patient rooms he came to another patient who was in the corner, frightened like a man trying to hide from a beast, with his hands trying to protect his head and he was repeating 'please Layla, please don't hit me', so the inspector asked the resident doctor, what is his story, the doctor replied "he married Layla".
With emotion and sentimental attachments the reality is between the first patient and the last one.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
I picked up some Sultani 1982 from Hamza/Kymya, which I'm pretty sure is the same oil. I'm still waiting for it to arrive. Some SQ collector must have unloaded a bunch of their collection recently because I'm seeing a lot of SQ stuff available right now from different vendors.
Interesting discussion between Mr. P and Habz up there. Has me contemplating why I fomo'ed so hard and spent so much money on an oil. I'm only a few years into collecting, and Oud Royale has always been talked about as the holy grail. If not for the scent alone, but also what legend tells it's introduction into the market did for the growth of the oud community in the early days in the west.
I guess more than anything I wanted to own a piece of oud history. But I also got bit by the SQ bug awhile ago, and everything I've tried has been incredible, so it was justifiable.
I love aged oil, especially those from reputable vendors purporting to come from the SQ distillery, I love Maroke oud, and I love collecting oud treasures.
IMHO I consider these super expensive oils viable to purchase if they are considered an investment like gold and silver ( something one oud vendor has been using as a marketing technique to attract and expand the clientele circle). I invested a fortune out of my own hard earned- money and bought some of the most coveted ouds in the market back in the day and they have been aging in my shoebox inside my drawer for the past 14 years in almost pristine and untouched condition. When I realized that the money I put on those tiny bottles won't be yielding back any reasonable profits, a sense of extreme and deep disappointment took over me. It's not that the ouds themselves are not worth the money- not in the 2010s that is, but when you look at the status quo of the current jinkoh oil market, especially the high end ones, all the prices they command will jeopardize your financial status and make the idea of buying them utterly illogical. From an Islamic perspective, however, scholars are on a consensus that if the majority of the money you have earned were to buy you fragrances that adorn you, and those around you, being a source of joy and beauty, then the money spent is a form of charity. I have always told those around me that all the money I spend on personal amenities, hobby- related ones, always left a bitter taste on my soul ( a sense of guilt, to be exact). The case is not the same with oud, though. I didn't remorse not a single Saudi Riyal spent on them WHEN I use them on my way to the Masjid, meeting loved ones, family gatherings and visits. However, spending those fortunes with the premise that I will someday sell the expensive ones at two folds their original price turned out to be a naive strategy. So $1500, $2500, and nowadays $5000 and $10000 are prices set specifically to three categories of clients, tycoons and royalties, collectors and antique-heads and the naive with a hazy market vision (the ones most prone to suffer a financial blow). I still consider myself fortunate to have owned oud oils on par with those used by sultans and emperors, but the money over quantity ratio lacks equilibrium.One thing I'd add to the discussion, despite the oil potentially being overhyped, the recent increase in supply since 2020, has meant that people aren't expected to pay 5-10000 usd for 2.5g.
2-2500 usd a for a bottle is relatively good value for money to me.
Its a 43 year old oil, its Sultani, and its one of the few meraukes where the profile is done correctly.
I sold a Maroke in 2022, that was from 2016 and had a similar incensey but more patchouli heavy profile.
Even the Maroke 2000 profile is pretty similar to Sultani 1982, and there are a few other similar Maroke oils out there - but none are as perfect as Sultani 1982.
Many of us, myself included, prefer oud to be like a perfume, I'm not a fan of Gasoline or Barn notes at all. Oils like this allow the oud to be crowd pleasing and very versatile, if I'm spending 4-5+ figures on a watch, perfume etc. I want to have the freedom to wear it anywhere in any circumstance.
My previous comment was supposed to be a response to this message but I didn't quote it properly. I can very much relate to your experience here, I have very much appreciated the exotic spectrum of aromas that the wilder materials bring, but these days I'm getting the most bang for my buck from some of these kinam extractions and it's nice knowing or at least thinking I know that these are all inoculation free, continuing to be produced sustainably etc.Co2 “oil” made from wild hainan
This oil is cheap, $30 a gram but yet somehow one of my favorite oils of all time.
Such a clear hainan profile, somehow projects well enough and lasts a decent while.
The combination of this profile and price point creates a unique experience for me.
I wouldn’t say “best” but more so “favorite.” Which is humorous considering it’s one of the first oils I really got into years ago and Ive spent stupid money since “searching” and trying so many other oils, only to come full circle.