With all the talk of tigerwood oils and their crossover with phenolic / diesel notes, I remembered I got a sample of EO's Tigerwood 1991 with a recent purchase and decided that today's the day.
Thankfully I'm now secure enough in my own olfactory tastes that I feel like I can smell past the hyperbolic marketing copy to get a better assessment these days. TW 91 is good, but to me it's not a replacement for the elevated diesel intensity of TW Royale. It does have something of an iodine / diesel / isobutyl quinoline leather type thing, but this is dialled back much more than the blast of TWR. It reminded me a little of the diesel note in JS' Emperor of Kedah v2, which also has a touch of squeaky patent leather saffron in amongst the purple florals.
It's a nice leathery Tigerwood oil - I haven't smelled the 90 or 95 so I can't make a comparison there, my reference points are Al Hashimi's Malay Atiq, Yusa's Harimau and Isan or TOL's Kodai Ka (I wasn't a big fan of kodai ka though so I ended up passing it on) - Tigerwood Terengganu from Kymya is a bit of an outlier and isn't similar to any of these in my opinion. To my nose, none of these tigerwood oils have a diesel note, they are all just elevated resinous leathery tobacco bombs with other auxilary notes to different degrees. For my money, they are all better than TW 91, not only in value for money but also because they hold their structure throughout the entire wear and have excellent, long-tailed dry downs. TW 91 on the other hand started to lose ground towards the dry down, and started to smell a little overcooked and charred - kind of lacking the resinous depth that I want in a vintage malay. If I remember correctly, I seem to remember thinking the same about TW Royale's heart and drydown despite how glorious the opening chapter is.
All in all, TW 91 is a good but not unmissable oil for the price (which looks like it will double at some unspecified point in the future too) and as per usual I'd argue your time and money is better spent waiting for a gem to come up amongst the vendors on this forum.
Now - can any of you habz heads tell me, is either Sultan Hijau or Ghazal 3 going to scratch my itch if I did decide I needed a diesel-forward malay in the collection? Despite how much I love all of the malays and tigerwoods I do have right now, it does feel like that specific note is something I'm missing. I remember Borneo Qi packing the diesel effect in quite heavily too if I remember it correctly.