I sampled Ceen before buying and was happy to pay $600 for a full bottle, it is well worth the money, even cheap at the price. To me it is a multi-faceted complex oil and much more than 'mushroom' and 'carrot seed', notes which I don't actually get from Ceen. I will buy a sample of FH to do my own comparison.
 
@Al Shareef Oudh

To summarize my thinking...I really want you hunderstand what Iam after from you insha ALLAH

I find that you do not give enough informations on your 4 factors.

If your oils was sale for 200 its enough. and you have cheaper oils that I ask nothing about (like khulood). but for 600 I need more infos. like for Hudhayl oud it is perfect, I have the wood, there is all details of the distillation in the description, thinking about buying a full bottle of the oud at 565 is not a problem, because I have enough information.

Read carefully my review please...I prefer ceen than FH...but the high price coupled to a lack of infos means that I will not buy more than a sample...And I am annoyed because ceen is beautiful.

When I buy a 600 oil, I want to know all details from the raw material to the distilation. Someone dont care...for me its a necessity. I can not content myself with basic information like with a 200 oil I buy every month. Because 600 oil is luxury, maybe not for everybody, but for me it is.
 
Last edited:
Ridhwan by Al Shareef Oudh,

A glimpse to the epic Al-Shareef I, full-blown unlocked dimensions of Oud A'meen, an epitome of how artistic oud blend should be.

The structure is constructed mainly on Malaysian oud of similar characteristics yet more complexity than of A'meen with its ambergrisified resin and added beautiful white chocolate on background of faint rose-like and strong red musky notes (not greenish jungly muskiness as in Oud Ahmad or Tigerwood Royale for example), augmented by luxurious leathery note that is reminiscent of AS-I, a signature of Al Shareef Oudh, wrapped up at the opening by the smoothness and refinement of the greatly aged Assamese oil Al Malek Hindi with its luxurious tamed barn, and the authentic cambodi oily sweet deliciousness of Oud Qais (I guess). There may be Indonesian Borneo characteristics start shinning in the heartnotes after the animalic notes settled down slightly but definitely there at the basenotes. The vaporous whiffs lifted by the latter that you get from time to time away from the site of application are oozing with oudiness. The long lasing drydown is just pure luxurious musky suede leather as of AS-I. All notes are in harmony with no isolated note overcomes or compromises the well-engineered construction till the end.

I really don't know why I haven't grabbed a bottle especially at the time when I had unlimited oud budget but sadly not the case at the moment! I think mostly because it's an acquired test not an easy love from the first sniff plus the price tag, although I appreciated its complex nuances and refinement immediately.

A heritage oud telling the story of a culture if I may add...
 
Last edited:
I would like to thank publicly @Al Shareef Oudh for his availability and kindness.

He contacted me privately to understand what my expectations were and try to answer them in the best way.
This is rare enough to be mentioned.

He offered to help me train my nose in order to be able to distinguish the nuances between the oud and thus be able to differentiate them.

It is true that there is little interest in having high-end oud if one does not make the difference with entry-level ouds.

I stop there because there is already enough Bollywood scene 😉

Barak'ALLAH oufik akhy lkarim
 
Al Shareef Oudh Ceen
VS
Imperial Oud fragrant harbour

1 little swipe of them on the hand and I sniff them for hours.

The opening point go to Ceen because I love this camphorik smell where FH smell metalic note (pot distil note) because of its youngness.

The heart note point go to ceen too because of it incredible mushroom (for me it is) note where FH is more woody...at this point the two oil are like twins with two minutes difference between them when born...Ceen is aged (4 years) where FH is freshly out of the pot. For oud oil...4 years is like 2/3H difference for new born, if you hunderstand what I mean. Both oil have this beautiful camphorik heart.

For the drydown its 30 secondes twins...and the point go to FH for its nuclear lasting!

2 for Ceen / 1 for FH

Now...

A point which is definitly very important for me ...the price.

Ceen is 600 where FH is 200!!!

Am I ready to pay 3 times more for a oud that is twins with an other...even if at the end I prefer Ceen...definitly not!

The point go to FH

Ceen 2 - FH 2

Its a perfect egality but if I take in consideration that the metalic opening (5 minutes not more) will disapear with 6 month (maybe less) aging...

...the winner is FH

Iam not ready to pay 3 times a oud for a single note (mushroom here) and aging, even if I love this note. I prefer to keep my bucks and buy 1KG of the best Paris mushroom and put my head in the bag before swiping FH...It worth the money ahahahah

At the end its two amazing oils by two super vendors.

I will keep my 0.2 sample of Ceen like a tresor for its mushroom note and greedly put big swipe of FH without thinking of the bank.
mashaallah akhi, very informative
 
If the tree/trees that were used to craft Fragrant Harbor were allowed to grow for a few more decades, they would produce KYARA😱😀

When I do side by side comparisons I end up appreciating what is unique about each oil, in the end they are like separate reviews😎
 
@Oudamberlove we are waiting your reviews about the two oils now 😉
 
My thoughts on AgarwoodAssam's Āsāma Garjana:

I generally shy away from full-on "classic" (i.e. barnyard) Hindi oud oils. Unlike many oud afficionados, I wasn't exposed to their smell when growing up and there was absolutely nothing that would prepare me for that type of olfactory sensation in my culture and environment. Oud generally is insanely complex and can take years for a new convert to wrap their mind around it. It was challenging enough for me to "get" even the more Western-friendly oud scent profiles like Borneo and Cambodian so the first time I tried an Assam oil (an old Oriscent classic), I was almost terrified 🙂 It was all war drums, horse hooves and heavy steps and clanking armour of marching troops. The raw primal energy was like a glimpse of a different world that is inhabited by heroes and villains, battling each other in earnest and living their lives to the fullest while we impatiently whip out our iPhones to check the Twitter feeds because the elevator ride is longer than 10 seconds. What can I possibly have in common with that violent and glorious world? It's too visceral and too real for someone like me!

Years passed and I still felt that I am too much of a wimp for the classic Hindi oud. I've dipped my toes into the gentler, well-behaved no-barn Hindis along the way and found them fascinating and enjoyable but subconsciously felt that while they shared much of their wilder cousins' DNA, something was missing from their composition - almost like looking at a doped up predator in a hazed slumber in front of a gawking audience. Well, I told myself - that's the compromise I have to make to enjoy a Hindi oud.

When I received a sample of an Āsāma Garjana (Assam Roars) from BengalRoots I didn't expect much from it. Sure, I am a sucker for any good quality pure oud and enjoy sampling even if just to see my previous ideas and opinions confirmed. After all, I sort of accepted the fact that the classic Hindi oud is not for me, it should be enjoyed by someone who grew up with it or lives in a place where that kind of a scent is socially accepted. The name of the oil, which translates as "Assam Roars" suggested like it would be an oil that wouldn't change my opinions in any way. Nevertheless, I was grateful to BengalRoots for the chance to try it an excited at the opportunity to sample a new oil from a genre that I am least familiar with.

The first time I opened the vial I was amazed at how diffusive the scent of the oil was - I didn't even have to sniff the plastic applicator, the aroma bloomed outwards and projected from a good distance. A first impression is often the most important and Āsāma Garjana didn't hesitate to greet me loud and clear 🙂 The scent was bright and vibrant, with a healthy dose of clean barn intertwined with sun-warmed wood and dried hay. I found myself surprised at actually LIKING the barn component; it's not violent, harsh and dismissive but instead vivacious, youthful and upbeat. It feels like a space filled with light and life, no darkness, mustiness or decay.

The barn diminishes very quickly and woodiness comes out. The scent clearly changes but the transformation is very subtle as the two qualities are so similar and so harmoniously related to each other it's hard to tell them apart at times. The barn can suddenly jump up again if the body temperature rises or recede almost entirely into its sibling woodiness. The scent remains sunny, bright and playful throughout. I was also surprised at how the scent stays detectable throughout the day, hardly any olfactory fatigue which often diminishes the perception of the aroma and takes away from the enjoyment of an oud.

I could never quite understand how oud can be described in terms of other smells, like coffee, raspberries, roses etc. When I read such descriptions I can't imagine what these can possibly smell like in the context of oud, so I try to stick to the concepts that make sense to me olfactorily - oudiness, woodiness, sweetness, bitterness, smokiness, resin, and a few even more subjective categories like diffusiveness, light/dark, young/old etc. Āsāma Garjana has the oudiness and woodiness in spades, the barn never quite goes away but becomes more of a nuance of the woody aspect, intermingled with sweet oudy quality. The mid-stage is great - the harmony between the barn and the wood aroma takes on an almost vibrating quality, as if they sing together in perfect synchronicity. The dry down is where the youthful playfulness finally takes a rest while the sweet universal oudiness persists, becoming sweeter and allowing the dried hay aroma to become more evident. I enjoy all three stages but the mid-stage is probably my favourite, that silent humming quality (pardon the paradoxical descriptive) of a perfect synergy of notes is something that I seek out and long for the most in oud oils.

The only quality that I wish this oil had more of is multilayered depth (for the lack of a better word). Or a wider dynamic range - which I understand to be an extended olfactory scale where the airy top notes and succulent heart notes are supported and amplified by low, deep bass notes. Āsāma Garjana is not devoid of the bassiness, but the deep notes are very polite and would definitely give the whole composition an additional oomph if they could be turned up. Having said that, I am not even sure this this is a valid observation, as I tend to compare whatever new oil I sample with my golden standard benchmarks, most of which are from some years ago when the oud scene was very different. Either way - Āsāma Garjana may not have the wizened depth of some of the legendary Hindi's of the past, but it's still dear to me for being my guide into the wonderful world of the classic Hindi oud and its signature note.

In short, Āsāma Garjana did not change my life, but I think I finally "get" what the classic Hindi lovers find in their beloved oils - the uncompromising vitality and the unmistakable vigor that a good Hindi can deliver. I not just understand that now but enjoy this quality that is hard to find in other oud genres, even among my most treasured and loved oils. Āsāma Garjana’s lively, bright and open presentation coupled with a harmonious unison on all the notes during its song make this oil very addictive (I smelled the heck out of my sample). Luckily, also very powerful, with only the tiniest amount needed make it sing at full volume. I also found myself reaching out for this oil to put on a small amount just before bedtime - there's something very soothing and comforting in its scent, and the drydown in the morning is a glorious welcome of the new day 🙂

I traded a few messages with BengalRoots and I understand that he's an individual who is not only interested in oud as a business venture, but someone who hears oud's poetry and has a deep passion for recreating "the Hindi" that made the Hindi the original oud loved and treasured for generations. I understand that his oils are offered at prices that make them a lot more accessible in a world where most (myself included) feel that they are hopelessly priced out of the market. I am very grateful to BengalRoots for his kind gesture of providing me a free sample and wish him every success that he deserves as someone who's not just a oud distiller and seller but a fellow ouddict himself! Hindi oud is possibly one of the least offered in the recent years as business follows the quickly vanishing wood to Thailand, Papua and Malaysia. Perhaps, Hindi oud is not quite as easy for a new oud convert to appreciate as some other scent profiles but it has the unique primordial energy that triggers some ancient genetic memories on the deepest level, and it has been "the oud" for a very long time. I hope BengalRoots is able to create more top notch oils in that proud tradition!

 
Nice to see you igor01 and a great review! I had given my address to bengalroots months ago but the sample never came. Sorry I missed it!
 
Has anyone tried Dr. Hindi from feel-oud?
 
Wow, epic review Igor01!!

Hindi's have been an acquired taste for me but I sure do enjoy them - right before bed is when I like them the most - the scent is very comforting and earthy, I become a simple, contented animal, ready to rest until morning..
 
@Igor01, Very nice review. I was fortunate enough to try Bengal Root's Melody, Barak ( That was aged Assamese) Ahom etc and special Assamese chips too. All of them were good especially Melody. I wanted to get a bottle of Melody but the entire lot got sold to a leading retailer in the Gulf .
 
@Bengal Roots - Asama Garjana

This is such an amazing classic Hindi for such a fair price. I put a little swipe on my left arm two days ago and I can still smell it.

It starts with the barnyard, then comes the leather, sweet honey, hay, fruits and spices. But the barnyard is there the whole trip. Then it smells like something sweet animalic, something like musk together with some oud and sweet/sour fruits and wood.

This is pure quality to my nose. And they are so generous. I bought wood and got oil samples with it for free. Now I regret that I didn't buy the oils. But at least now I know it's a safe buy.

Thank you very much
 
@Oudamberlove what you say is interesting...for me it change everythings if its confirmed by the vendor.

@Bengal Roots can you confirm?
 
Wow! I see where it is coming from. Boya will not age of over 6 months it will be wax formation & completely flat with no complexity. Apparently, another Indian dealer has conveyed this to a customer of mine as well claiming it is boya. I see it is getting nastier & murkier to deal online.

BARAKA TĀRAKĀ is not BOYA

Apparently, @Oudamberlove you also bought wood chips from me is that a boya too?
 
Back
Top