came upon a bottle of dilute l-muscone I made up a while back. This is a synthesized copy of the chemical that contributes the bulk of the body of the aroma to natural musk. Of course It doesn't remotely encapsulate the aroma of natural musk - instead it presents a highly refined narrow slice of the musk pie. Even if this is the dominant molecule that accounts for the main punch, it does not account for the rich broad complex array of notes that can only come from grains undergoing fermentation in a pod on a live deer.

I layered this with some patchoulol natural isolate, and at one point the two formed this really classic deep patchouli accord - it brought something into focus that I have smelled in the past but didn't realize exactly where it was coming from.

What is -fascinating- just from an educational point of view is to mix up something, check it out for a while, and then also try it with just a trace of the muscone. It's a funny material, transforming / exalting things without competing with them.

The pure muscone is surprising - when it is dilute (I am guessing at around the percentage that it's found in the grains) the connection to natural musk is clear. In higher concentrations it starts to resemble some of these artificial white musk / ambrettolide type scents. I don't know if this is an artifact of synthetic chemistry, or if it's just the nature of the molecule itself, and a natural isolate would be similar.

l-muscone and ambroxide are absurdly interesting molecules. i'm able to get a natural biotech/fermented ambroxide isolate, I wonder if this type of muscone will ever be a thing? for a number of reasons natural musk is not an option for me and I like these interesting alternatives… I love the botanical musks but the idea of a natural fermentation-made muscone is super appealing.
 
Last edited:
I don't know the level of snootiness on this thread but I am wearing Ajmal's Mukhallat Shams today. It is a nice synthetic hindi oud mukhallat vibe with mad longevity and sillage. Some days I go simple 🙂
There's naught wrong with a wee bit of Ajmal! When I'm feeling surly, and not likely to be around any of my sensitive family members, I like to put on a little swipe of the old AA musk gazelle! Stuff is a beast probably has synthetic materials but it is addictive and super rich. been a while since i have opened the tin it is sealed up in.
 
Last edited:
There's naught wrong with a wee bit of Ajmal! When I'm feeling surly, and not likely to be around any of my sensitive family members, I like to put on a little swipe of the old AA musk gazelle! Stuff is a beast probably has synthetic materials but it is addictive and super rich. been a while since i have opened the tin it is sealed up in.
Ah I remember the days of basenotes debates about whether AA musk gazelle was real musk !!! <3 I love it
 
Sulaym—HM Royal Jardin EdM
The one who dares to add musk to such an expensive and already perfect oil must be a brilliant and confident genius :
HM Royal Jardin OG to me is already a 10/10 rose-dominated rose-oud scent for me, but the added musk elevates the scent to the next level.
Compared to the OG version, Jardin EdM weakened the sweetness of the floral part and smoothed the sharpness of the transitional part. The musk here is detectable but not overpowering, gentle and graceful.
Then here comes the final boss: the maroke
The added musk leads the oud part to appear earlier, same vibe but apparently more pronounced and lasted way longer than the OG version.
Inhale and exhale, I kept sniffing it almost uncontrollably, just heavenly.
Jardin EdM is without doubt a phenomenal 10+/10 maroke-dominated rose-oud scent
Definitely full bottle worthy and luckily grabbed the last one
 
Last edited:
ASO - Yaqoot II (again)

After spending time with this apex attar I've come to the conclusion that the real magic is in the dry down. The opening is heavier on the oud with the musk gently surrounding the scent profile, but as it settles...the musk begins to bloom. Green, slightly earthy, sweet, nutty, powerful. Where does the oud begin and where does it end ? Where does the musk begin and where does it end ? I don't know, but that's the point. The combination is what makes it so great, its as though the oud and musk are one in perfect harmony.
 
Sulaym—HM Royal Jardin EdM
The one who dares to add musk to such an expensive and already perfect oil must be a brilliant and confident genius :
HM Royal Jardin OG to me is already a 10/10 rose-dominated rose-oud scent for me, but the added musk elevates the scent to the next level.
Compared to the OG version, Jardin EdM weakened the sweetness of the floral part and smoothed the sharpness of the transitional part. The musk here is detectable but not overpowering, gentle and graceful.
Then here comes the final boss: the maroke
The added musk leads the oud part to appear earlier, same vibe but apparently more pronounced and lasted way longer than the OG version.
Inhale and exhale, I kept sniffing it almost uncontrollably, just heavenly.
Jardin EdM is without doubt a phenomenal 10+/10 maroke-dominated rose-oud scent
Definitely full bottle worthy and luckily grabbed the last one
The musk version is superior to the original without a doubt.
 
I don't know the level of snootiness on this thread but I am wearing Ajmal's Mukhallat Shams today. It is a nice synthetic hindi oud mukhallat vibe with mad longevity and sillage. Some days I go simple 🙂
I just got this on Tuesday or Monday of this week. I had to buy it overseas as it’s not sold in the US except on eBay. It only cost me $49 but shipping was $20, and customs tax was another flat $20. Luckily I like it as it was a blind buy. 😀
 
Sulaym - Elysium Édition de Musc

Sulaym’s Elysium ÈDM opens with a soft, airy sweetness from the florals and ambergris that feels instantly comforting, then settles into a clean, velvety musk that wraps everything in a warm glow. It’s one of those scents that feels effortlessly smooth. It’s quietly luxurious without trying too hard.
 

Attachments

  • [Ouddict.com] Attar/Mukhallat of the Day
    Sulaym edm .webp
    54 KB · Views: 61
The floral-ambergris profile is the soul of the fragrance. The dry down does have an orris velvet glow which actually comes from the musk and Ylang Ylang interacting with each other. Great review as always thanks @mobyus. Elysium II takes inspiration from Elysium ÉdM but it will have Tibetan musk in it and a new mystery oud, yet to be unveiled.
Elysium II ? When is that due for release if you don't mind me asking
 
The floral-ambergris profile is the soul of the fragrance. The dry down does have an orris velvet glow which actually comes from the musk and Ylang Ylang interacting with each other. Great review as always thanks @mobyus. Elysium II takes inspiration from Elysium ÉdM but it will have Tibetan musk in it and a new mystery oud, yet to be unveiled.
Elysium II ?! This is going to be interesting.
 
Lupus & Vega - Prayers/Wordless

I simply love this blend. I cycle through Shamama, Sanctum, Aureum, and Prayers/Wordless before going to sleep. It’s no longer exclusively a Shamama show.

I no longer want it before bed, I NEED it before bed. The ingredients that go into these blends don’t just induce sleep for me. They induce a bedside euphoria that reflects the quality that goes into them. And from my many conversations with @Joe is that he doesn’t compromise on quality ingredients. I wake up in a good mood every time.

This is not a commercial.
 
Lupus & Vega - Prayers/Wordless

I simply love this blend. I cycle through Shamama, Sanctum, Aureum, and Prayers/Wordless before going to sleep. It’s no longer exclusively a Shamama show.

I no longer want it before bed, I NEED it before bed. The ingredients that go into these blends don’t just induce sleep for me. They induce a bedside euphoria that reflects the quality that goes into them. And from my many conversations with @Joe is that he doesn’t compromise on quality ingredients. I wake up in a good mood every time.

This is not a commercial.
Go @Joe!! 😎
 
Lupus & Vega - Prayers/Wordless

I simply love this blend. I cycle through Shamama, Sanctum, Aureum, and Prayers/Wordless before going to sleep. It’s no longer exclusively a Shamama show.

I no longer want it before bed, I NEED it before bed. The ingredients that go into these blends don’t just induce sleep for me. They induce a bedside euphoria that reflects the quality that goes into them. And from my many conversations with @Joe is that he doesn’t compromise on quality ingredients. I wake up in a good mood every time.

This is not a commercial.
Thank you very much for recognizing the materials, @mobyus . There are some vendors that will be happy to see their materials put to good use! Now, if only it helped with my insomnia, I'd be quite happy.
 
I treat this thread as a catch all for any aromas that are not oud or sandalwood, so...

Patchoulol natural isolate in ethanol is my random scent of the moment. Not a substitute for a full rich aged dark patchouli, but an absolutely amazing little wedge of the full patchouli pie-chart. Harmonizes soooo well with oud and it has some oudy woodiness of its own that brings some borneo oud to mind. I sometimes get an aroma that reminds me of the smell of cork - as from a freshly opened bottle of wine. Really the smell of the cork itself - that somewhat musty, earthy note that brings dark cellars and age to mind. I really enjoy this material, comes as a white crystalline powder. Probably safer for me to carry the little roller bottle of it diluted in alcohol that I use, than to be walking around with the pure stuff. Busting out a little vial of white powder, tapping little piles onto my wrist, and taking sniffs isn't a good look, apparently. anyway this stuff is basically like camphor extracted from patchouli - how cool is that? And it brings something to the table that camphor offers (and borneo camphor but without the BO note), and if you are fans of those materials you deserve to check this stuff out - cool, crystalline beautiful patchouli camphor aroma. The perfect camphor-like substance for me. 🙂 it also reminds me of walking around in bamboo groves, when the leaves decay they must release a little bit of borneol or something like it

IMG_3577.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Lupus & Vega - Sanctum Aureum

Sanctum Aureum is where resin, wood, and flowers come together in perfect harmony. Golden florals Omani frankincense , and soft citrus are notes I get.. i love it as it dries down, it turns warm and deeply serene, and showcases the Mysore Sandalwood. Simply beautiful.


@Joe
 
Back
Top