Yeah, Taif absolutely can lose its sparkle over time, especially if it’s been stored in conditions that push oxidation. In this case though, whatever aging it went through seems to have acted more like a slow maceration than a straight evaporation oxidation cycle. I’m not saying it stayed ‘fresh’, it hasn’t. But it hasn’t gone linear or waxy either, which is usually the death sign for old rose. The aldehydic bite is toned down, and what’s left is that dry, spiced Taif signature folded into the Maroke. I've also got Sulaym's Taif on its own, and that one is noticeably more crisp and brighter in the opening. I can’t verify the exact chemical pathway after 40 years, but on skin it behaves more like a matured attar than an over aged rose absolute. It feels integrated, not faded/muted.