anexplorer
Oud Beginner
Just received a few attars from Gulabsingh Johrimal (Kashi, Vajra, and Hina, Shamama, and Musk Amber from their 1460 lineup). Testing them all out...
interesting. did you get my bottle of PI perhaps?pheromone intense and king saud by scent talks
king saud is nice, it reminds me of a specific ghaliya that costs much more. the structure is very much of a high quality resinous, incensy and sweet oud, that the musk and supporting elements help to structure and add depth.
pheromone intense- i thought this was going to be a musk bomb naturally. i believe this is the best gourmand cafe/coffee attar i have smelled. it sits, in my opinion, perfectly between the two heavyweights i’ve smelled in this category- elixir attars mythique and sultan pashas tabac grande. mythique is lovely but too decadent and chocolatey for more regular wear, though also incredible in its own right the sweetness and overly gourmand quality makes it that i only reach for it on special occasions. tabac grand i absolutely love but sometimes sultan pashas use of synthetics makes the notes drone on a bit for me-but one of his best compositions. more atmospheric than mythique which focuses on the coffee and sweets
pheromone intense really hits the coffee note perfectly, not too bitter or sweetened and gourmand, that’s a really tough accord to pull out. the musk makes it smell more alive and it hums with a slightly smokey note that never goes acrid. there is background notes of tobacco and resinous oud incense qualities. this is a masterpiece in my opinion
Thoughts?Just received a few attars from Gulabsingh Johrimal (Kashi, Vajra, and Hina, Shamama, and Musk Amber from their 1460 lineup). Testing them all out...
I really liked this one.A majmua sample from An Najwa.
I do really like Vajra. The tulsi makes it stand out and I like the smoky-spicy-sweetness. I found Musk Amber really nice too, I believe it uses Jatamansi/Indian spikenard for the muskiness, I smell a little of it in here. I need to test out the remaining a little more, but first thoughts:Thoughts?
Attar Mohd. Ayub & Co. or S. Md. Ayub Md. Yaqub?Mohd Ayub- Super Shamama
A few hours after applying, I suspect I’m not going to be blown away by the performance but it sure smells lovely. I really need to try more from Mohd Ayub.
The Ayub sans Yaqub. I’d be curious to try some of Yaqub’s offerings as well.Attar Mohd. Ayub & Co. or S. Md. Ayub Md. Yaqub?
The name is always confusing as they're different but similar sounding, but I like Yaqub's stuff generally better. Prob better still out there, but my shamama experience more limited.
I'm no expert, but yaqub, like I think many of the kannauj houses makes things both traditionally with natural materials and a deg, as well as more cheaply/mass produced, so it's really product by product... unfortunately. Prob much like Ajmal, which does have pure ouds and prestige products, but to grow, also makes a wide swath of products across all tiers/types/costs, as a necessity to grow and scale. There's certainly more artisinal houses in the area, but with even yaqub being hard to source stateside, they become far more difficult to track down and source and sample.I have occasionally seen references to these manufacturers over the years, but I've never seen any reviews from people who were collectors and I have never been able to figure out if they are all authentic or mostly authentic, artisanal, mass market, etc..