Been thinking that when i approach a list of ingredients as 'attar', i appreciate density, a composition of notes. But that same list as 'perfume', i think in terms of space and storytelling and wondered what exactly makes the difference. Looking at Guerlain's vintage Vetiver, which has been reverse engineered to great extent, it's interesting to see how he used both the complete botanical and isolates to create a lighter version of the botanical - light in the sense of taking up less space - that, however, keeps its soul. Probably another rabbit hole to trace that technique back to 1889's Jicky.
Guess my 'raw botanicals only' stance may be conflicting with the way i think a perfume should behave. But to my defence 🙂 i would not have expected it to go all the way back to 1889..
Otoh, could be very interesting to try develop an idea into both versions. Think i've already bought that train ticket without knowing..
my 2 cents for whatever it's worth, hopefully at least two cents: I think any and all materials are fair game of course and the full range of materials is the real basis for "The Art" in a broad sense, but when it comes to individual art I think part of the fun is in restricting your options and trying to solve problems under constraints; this was a common teaching approach imposed by my various art teachers over the years. Limiting someone to a set period of time, or set of colors, a specific medium or tool etc.. and of course there have been brilliant artists over the years in all kinds of different media - the medium really doesn't define or constrain the
beauty of the art. a painting that is just made with watercolor paint is not better or worse than a multimedia painting or an oil painting etc.. either can be sublime in there are probably infinite sublime variations in both categories, I'm confident in this 100% and I think this applies to perfume 100%.
so it's just a matter of what captures the interest and imagination of the person making the art. I think someone who really knows how to paint can make something wonderful out of oils or watercolor or mixed media, and of course mixed media and oils allow for some
literal effects like impasto or glossy or metallic - things that can just be alluded to by shading in watercolor - but it's not like one medium has more or less potential for beauty than the other at least as I see it. Obviously mixed medium allows for a wider possibility of approach to creating an image and allows for certain types of images that would be impossible with a different medium. in my experience the perfumes that incorporate synthetics tend to be overwhelming and heavy-handed, with
many exceptions of course, and I personally specifically appreciate the shifting and ephemeral and complex nature of the naturals.
Art is one thing, manufacturing something and profit margins and literal reproducibility and all of that is quite another, and the synthetics offer a real advantage there obviously. As has already been stated and is obvious they offer all kinds of interesting alternative elements and performances, and they also allow one to avoid using products associated with animal cruelty or ecological endangerment like civet and musk (trapping of animals is often far from humane), spikenard, rosewood, etc.
I have a small collection of synthetics and I dabble with them regularly l, but any serious creations I make are just from the naturals, I enjoy that arbitrary constraint, it makes the selection less overwhelming, and I like the sense of connecting even superficially with historical or traditional fragrances. For me it's worth the fact that there are certain types of perfumes that I won't be able to make and I may not be able to achieve precise reproducibility or mass batch production, or profit margins that would be acceptable to a board of directors etc., (this I recognize is a luxury reflecting the fact that i am not dependent on it for income and can merely dabble)