If this matures without weird surprises, I don't think there's much to improve or change.
Ofcourse, it doesn't
Back to drawingboard 🧐

Edit
Basically back to #1 with the sweet birch added.
#3 seemed nice fresh made, but after a bit of shelf life the bittergreen open seems to have made friends with the vetiver and the note now remains present all the time. Ain't very nose friendly.
But #1 actually mellowed from it's initial green OD, yet all could be a bit more open, and a tad more vetiver would be nice. Shelved again, to see if the birch will do the trick..
 
Last edited:
Btw. If you are as frugal as me and try to recycle empty vials, (attar) bottles and such, but find it hard to get rid of the scent completely:

Bowl of warm water, bit of (liquid) laundry detergent, soak 2-3 hrs, cold water rinse. Done.
 
Childhood petrichor
I was trying to balance some patch and rose as part of something i'm working on, and using skin for testpatches. Now i'm not that keen on rose, so when done i went for a good rinse to derose.

Funny thing happened, sniffing to check if 'it' was gone, i got this time machine flashback to childhood, walking in the street while it rained. Makes sense if you think about it, violets and roses being the standard front yard deco where i lived. So we get faint rose and faint patch on a skin that still smells wet, pretty much equal to the faint rose, wet earth and wet kid walking in the rain.
If only i knew how to make that wet skin scent, i would do a Time Machine project 🙂

Maybe i do a faint rose-patch 'water' to use post shower for a brief moment of joy 🌦️
It certainly sounds like you had an “ah ha” moment and you should follow it through. Another rose, even muted, and patch would seem like any other one. But a subtle, watery patch from childhood memory—that’s original.
 
It certainly sounds like you had an “ah ha” moment and you should follow it through. Another rose, even muted, and patch would seem like any other one. But a subtle, watery patch from childhood memory—that’s original.
Maybe a 5% eau de toilette:
Ambretteseed for skin,
A hint of violetleaf abs for the moisture effect,
Rose gallica and light patch as they caused the effect to begin with.
Hmm..

🙂 And ditch the contradicting name, 'The Rain Child project' is better 🙂
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Joe
Maybe a 5% eau de toilette:
Ambretteseed for skin,
A hint of violetleaf abs for the moisture effect,
Rose gallica and light patch as they caused the effect to begin with.
Hmm..

🙂 And ditch the contradicting name, 'The Rain Child project' is better 🙂
much better, i agree. nothing's so simle than to name your perfume after two materials. Very, um, Jo Malone, even though i've done it before, lol.
 
Been thinking that when i approach a list of ingredients as 'attar', i appreciate density, a composition of notes. But that same list as 'perfume', i think in terms of space and storytelling and wondered what exactly makes the difference. Looking at Guerlain's vintage Vetiver, which has been reverse engineered to great extent, it's interesting to see how he used both the complete botanical and isolates to create a lighter version of the botanical - light in the sense of taking up less space - that, however, keeps its soul. Probably another rabbit hole to trace that technique back to 1889's Jicky.

Guess my 'raw botanicals only' stance may be conflicting with the way i think a perfume should behave. But to my defence 🙂 i would not have expected it to go all the way back to 1889..

Otoh, could be very interesting to try develop an idea into both versions. Think i've already bought that train ticket without knowing..
 
It's certainly interesting to try to do one naturals only and one naturals+synthetics. Synthetics can still yield amazing natural smelling results and improve and correct aspects, and becomes more like a puzzle, as you said, telling a story and space. More refinement options. Neither is right or wrong, and at least synthetics are generally wildly cheap and available in small amounts. Something like perfumers world will sell you 100 1ml bottles for like $100 for the basics, or bulkaroma or other places, so it's a cheap experiment
 
Been thinking that when i approach a list of ingredients as 'attar', i appreciate density, a composition of notes. But that same list as 'perfume', i think in terms of space and storytelling and wondered what exactly makes the difference. Looking at Guerlain's vintage Vetiver, which has been reverse engineered to great extent, it's interesting to see how he used both the complete botanical and isolates to create a lighter version of the botanical - light in the sense of taking up less space - that, however, keeps its soul. Probably another rabbit hole to trace that technique back to 1889's Jicky.

Guess my 'raw botanicals only' stance may be conflicting with the way i think a perfume should behave. But to my defence 🙂 i would not have expected it to go all the way back to 1889..

Otoh, could be very interesting to try develop an idea into both versions. Think i've already bought that train ticket without knowing..
my 2 cents for whatever it's worth, hopefully at least two cents: I think any and all materials are fair game of course and the full range of materials is the real basis for "The Art" in a broad sense, but when it comes to individual art I think part of the fun is in restricting your options and trying to solve problems under constraints; this was a common teaching approach imposed by my various art teachers over the years. Limiting someone to a set period of time, or set of colors, a specific medium or tool etc.. and of course there have been brilliant artists over the years in all kinds of different media - the medium really doesn't define or constrain the beauty of the art. a painting that is just made with watercolor paint is not better or worse than a multimedia painting or an oil painting etc.. either can be sublime in there are probably infinite sublime variations in both categories, I'm confident in this 100% and I think this applies to perfume 100%.

so it's just a matter of what captures the interest and imagination of the person making the art. I think someone who really knows how to paint can make something wonderful out of oils or watercolor or mixed media, and of course mixed media and oils allow for some literal effects like impasto or glossy or metallic - things that can just be alluded to by shading in watercolor - but it's not like one medium has more or less potential for beauty than the other at least as I see it. Obviously mixed medium allows for a wider possibility of approach to creating an image and allows for certain types of images that would be impossible with a different medium. in my experience the perfumes that incorporate synthetics tend to be overwhelming and heavy-handed, with many exceptions of course, and I personally specifically appreciate the shifting and ephemeral and complex nature of the naturals.

Art is one thing, manufacturing something and profit margins and literal reproducibility and all of that is quite another, and the synthetics offer a real advantage there obviously. As has already been stated and is obvious they offer all kinds of interesting alternative elements and performances, and they also allow one to avoid using products associated with animal cruelty or ecological endangerment like civet and musk (trapping of animals is often far from humane), spikenard, rosewood, etc.

I have a small collection of synthetics and I dabble with them regularly l, but any serious creations I make are just from the naturals, I enjoy that arbitrary constraint, it makes the selection less overwhelming, and I like the sense of connecting even superficially with historical or traditional fragrances. For me it's worth the fact that there are certain types of perfumes that I won't be able to make and I may not be able to achieve precise reproducibility or mass batch production, or profit margins that would be acceptable to a board of directors etc., (this I recognize is a luxury reflecting the fact that i am not dependent on it for income and can merely dabble)
 
Last edited:
It's certainly interesting to try to do one naturals only and one naturals+synthetics. Synthetics can still yield amazing natural smelling results and improve and correct aspects, and becomes more like a puzzle, as you said, telling a story and space. More refinement options. Neither is right or wrong, and at least synthetics are generally wildly cheap and available in small amounts. Something like perfumers world will sell you 100 1ml bottles for like $100 for the basics, or bulkaroma or other places, so it's a cheap experiment
I primarily work in naturals, but I am opening a second line that will be semi-synthetics because indeed you are right. For the most part, save substances that have been found to be neurons otherwise toxic (nitrous anyone?!), there is nothing inherently wrong with synthetics. But if you want the uniqueness of a well-blended all natural, I recommend you stick with all naturals then!
 
my 2 cents for whatever it's worth, hopefully at least two cents: I think any and all materials are fair game of course and the full range of materials is the real basis for "The Art" in a broad sense, but when it comes to individual art I think part of the fun is in restricting your options and trying to solve problems under constraints; this was a common teaching approach imposed by my various art teachers over the years. Limiting someone to a set period of time, or set of colors, a specific medium or tool etc.. and of course there have been brilliant artists over the years in all kinds of different media - the medium really doesn't define or constrain the beauty of the art. a painting that is just made with watercolor paint is not better or worse than a multimedia painting or an oil painting etc.. either can be sublime in there are probably infinite sublime variations in both categories, I'm confident in this 100% and I think this applies to perfume 100%.

so it's just a matter of what captures the interest and imagination of the person making the art. I think someone who really knows how to paint can make something wonderful out of oils or watercolor or mixed media, and of course mixed media and oils allow for some literal effects like impasto or glossy or metallic - things that can just be alluded to by shading in watercolor - but it's not like one medium has more or less potential for beauty than the other at least as I see it. Obviously mixed medium allows for a wider possibility of approach to creating an image and allows for certain types of images that would be impossible with a different medium. in my experience the perfumes that incorporate synthetics tend to be overwhelming and heavy-handed, with many exceptions of course, and I personally specifically appreciate the shifting and ephemeral and complex nature of the naturals.

Art is one thing, manufacturing something and profit margins and literal reproducibility and all of that is quite another, and the synthetics offer a real advantage there obviously. As has already been stated and is obvious they offer all kinds of interesting alternative elements and performances, and they also allow one to avoid using products associated with animal cruelty or ecological endangerment like civet and musk (trapping of animals is often far from humane), spikenard, rosewood, etc.

I have a small collection of synthetics and I dabble with them regularly l, but any serious creations I make are just from the naturals, I enjoy that arbitrary constraint, it makes the selection less overwhelming, and I like the sense of connecting even superficially with historical or traditional fragrances. For me it's worth the fact that there are certain types of perfumes that I won't be able to make and I may not be able to achieve precise reproducibility or mass batch production, or profit margins that would be acceptable to a board of directors etc., (this I recognize is a luxury reflecting the fact that i am not dependent on it for income and can merely dabble)
I agree that restriction is an excellent teacher. And a restriction to botanicals will not only teach how to compose the desired scent with different botanicals and different methods of extraction, but also how certain botanicals can influence how you experience the scent, without being visible themselves. That alone can easily fill my spare time until death interferes. As an hobbyist one has full freedom to mix up 30% oakmoss with 20% cold pressed bergamot. Thats just a matter of knowing your own sensitivities.

So one could argue there is no need to have a shelf full of chemicals unless that is what you like to work with for whatever reason.
Reaching for some 'special fx' type of chemical without even trying to get what you want with botanicals may even seem a sort of lazyness to put in some effort.

That said, i also experience that a formula can only fill 100%. So i can use, say, 80% to get the overall impression right and allow for 20% helpers. If i cant get it to fit, something has got to give, unless i can find or make a stronger version with the same quality. It may well be my inexperience or the lack of having multiple versions of each botanical, but it seems to make everything rather dense or crowded.

Like in La Verde it is really giving me a hard time to get to keep the desired intensity of the vetiver. I thought i could trade off some oakmoss for more vetiver but that then has an effect elsewere. Now in this case, the oakmoss is home made and i can do a bottle of a stronger version to gain some room for the vertiver, which i think is the preferred way to go about in this case.

But it also made me curious how a true master from the past dealt with it. And they seem to create space, both in the composition as in the formula by splitting up a note in part finest quality botanical, part isolate that lifts the desired aspects of that botanical.
So i'm not talking about tossing in iso super e or ambreine or whatever their names are for instant longivity and sillage to make yet another scent bomb 🙂 but about looking at a botanical and figuring out how i can put it on the map without using up 20% of the formula.

But i'm also aware that it may be a faulty line of thought. Maybe after swiping pure oils and blends, there is no going back. Or maybe it turns out fun to work out an idea in both directions, idk..
 
this was a common teaching approach imposed by my various art teachers over the years. Limiting someone to a set period of time, or set of colors, a specific medium or tool etc..

but it's not like one medium has more or less potential for beauty than the other at least as I see it.
But i'm also aware that it may be a faulty line of thought. Maybe after swiping pure oils and blends, there is no going back. Or maybe it turns out fun to work out an idea in both directions, idk..

I'd push back on 'there is no going back', or such hardline stances that using naturals only, forever, is just the best way to learn. A teacher assigning that something should be done in this form or that is an amazing learning tool as MrP mentions. This week/course is watercolors, the next one photography, there is value not only in the depth of learning that specific toolset/limitation, but also in the breadth.

An artist who limits themself to only graphite pencil their entire career, schooling onward, and refuses to even try color to experiment with, to learn, misses the contrast and valuable information on why or what their own monochrome is adding or excels at. A painter who willfully refuses to even familiarize themselves with the basics of photography, or derides it as 'less pure', i think is worse off for it, as even a brief experimentation with photography can teach them relevant information about lighting and composition that is transferrable, even if they never go back to photography again. The goal is knowledge, and in art there are no rules, so forcing oneself into some strict framework or ruleset even when it comes to learning I fear is troublesome, and the opposite of what the teachers push. And who knows, especially as a student, you may find you actually enjoy photography more than pencil drawing, no harm in the attempt, only potential upsides.

Just attempting or familiarizing yourself with other artforms doesnt mean you no longer can make a pure pencil drawing as your main craft. Don't let vanity get in the way of knowledge IMO.

It's also not all or nothing... If your goal was an all naturals composition, and you had a jasmine and pondered to yourself 'hm, i wonder what a more indole forward jasmine would do to this', you could go out and buy 3 more expensive jasmins to attempt, sure, but it would be faster/cheaper to cut an aliquot of it, toss in $0.001 indole, judge it, add a bit more, repeat, and rule it out or confirm suspicions, and then you can go into buying a more indole forward jasmine based on information not assumption or guess. Your end composition remains 'pure', but you've used tools to help inform knowledge and decisions. Even for a fine traditional artisinal woodworker, using a tablesaw for mockups or to make fixtures is not incompatible with the craft.
 
Last edited:
I agree that restriction is an excellent teacher. And a restriction to botanicals will not only teach how to compose the desired scent with different botanicals and different methods of extraction, but also how certain botanicals can influence how you experience the scent, without being visible themselves. That alone can easily fill my spare time until death interferes. As an hobbyist one has full freedom to mix up 30% oakmoss with 20% cold pressed bergamot. Thats just a matter of knowing your own sensitivities.

So one could argue there is no need to have a shelf full of chemicals unless that is what you like to work with for whatever reason.
Reaching for some 'special fx' type of chemical without even trying to get what you want with botanicals may even seem a sort of lazyness to put in some effort.

That said, i also experience that a formula can only fill 100%. So i can use, say, 80% to get the overall impression right and allow for 20% helpers. If i cant get it to fit, something has got to give, unless i can find or make a stronger version with the same quality. It may well be my inexperience or the lack of having multiple versions of each botanical, but it seems to make everything rather dense or crowded.

Like in La Verde it is really giving me a hard time to get to keep the desired intensity of the vetiver. I thought i could trade off some oakmoss for more vetiver but that then has an effect elsewere. Now in this case, the oakmoss is home made and i can do a bottle of a stronger version to gain some room for the vertiver, which i think is the preferred way to go about in this case.

But it also made me curious how a true master from the past dealt with it. And they seem to create space, both in the composition as in the formula by splitting up a note in part finest quality botanical, part isolate that lifts the desired aspects of that botanical.
So i'm not talking about tossing in iso super e or ambreine or whatever their names are for instant longivity and sillage to make yet another scent bomb 🙂 but about looking at a botanical and figuring out how i can put it on the map without using up 20% of the formula.

But i'm also aware that it may be a faulty line of thought. Maybe after swiping pure oils and blends, there is no going back. Or maybe it turns out fun to work out an idea in both directions, idk..


I have a couple of bins dedicated to isolates and aroma chemicals, some are quite interesting and some are just beautiful on their own and I end up wearing them like a perfume. I like the thought of using them as you described to boost / draw attention to (etc.) certain aspects of the natural materials that may be less than obvious.

I keep dilute l-muscone and fermentation-produced ambroxide on hand for layering when i want to get a general sense of what musk or ambergris might add to a blend. layering with those two can be really fascinating!
 
I'd push back on 'there is no going back', or such hardline stances that using naturals only, forever, is just the best way to learn.
Not as hardline stance, but i may discover that i prefer such choice after all. While experiments with isolates may even induce another view on how to balance the naturals to get what i want.
You can abandon a path but the lessons stay.

Like in my job i learned sewing on a vintage machine, switched to a modern one, which made me aware of my preference for vintage but it also changed how i view the machine which allows me to utilise it better - if that makes any sense.

I like your jasmine example, to do a what if quickly, didn't think of that 🙂
 
Instantly in love ❤️ what a beautiful scent

[Ouddict.com] MFH - Experiments & Materials

Anthoxanthum Odoratum (sweet fernal grass) absolue, Biolandes

[Ouddict.com] MFH - Experiments & Materials
 
I have a couple of bins dedicated to isolates and aroma chemicals, some are quite interesting and some are just beautiful on their own and I end up wearing them like a perfume. I like the thought of using them as you described to boost / draw attention to (etc.) certain aspects of the natural materials that may be less than obvious.

I keep dilute l-muscone and fermentation-produced ambroxide on hand for layering when i want to get a general sense of what musk or ambergris might add to a blend. layering with those two can be really fascinating!
The only thing i worry about is the kind of duo-lingo between the oil and perfume world. Like i love vetiver and am slow but steady collecting different versions. But in a vetiver forward perfume. odds are i wont recognise any of them in the almost abstract thing that they consider a vetiver note.
I don't know how much you can scale down the complete botanical before it loses identity like that. Experiments wil tell.
 
I primarily work in naturals, but I am opening a second line that will be semi-synthetics because indeed you are right. For the most part, save substances that have been found to be neurons otherwise toxic (nitrous anyone?!), there is nothing inherently wrong with synthetics. But if you want the uniqueness of a well-blended all natural, I recommend you stick with all naturals then!
Your line of thinking is correct, because I haven't yet discovered a perfume made entirely from natural ingredients.
 
Your line of thinking is correct, because I haven't yet discovered a perfume made entirely from natural ingredients.
They're out there. Hiram Green and mandy apfel are two more well known ones outside the artisans here.

But in a vetiver forward perfume. odds are i wont recognise any of them in the almost abstract thing that they consider a vetiver note.
I don't know how much you can scale down the complete botanical before it loses identity like that. Experiments wil tell.
Commercial frags scale back naturals fairly aggressively in a large part due to cost. Vetivers fairly cheap, but compared to like iso e, it's positively a luxury. If you wanted to keep the vetiver note, you absolutely could keep it fairly easily. It's fairly bold and tenacous, so it doesn't easily get stomped out or pushed to the back unless you scale it way back. Could also look at synthetic components in the same realm to augment, veriveryl acetate is pretty common and could yield interesting results. Mostly natural derived fraction just acetic acid reacted iirc.. so depending on your strictness of definition, natural anyway.

I agree that a lot of commercial frags take liberties with notes, 'sandalwood' note is some weird idealized version that's just weird and goes pickley. 'oud' note is ... Not oudy. And so on. Patchouli is almost always hidden away to a whisper. It's not that synths overpowered them, but that the perfumer desired them to be the way they turned out.
 
They're out there. Hiram Green and mandy apfel are two more well known ones outside the artisans here.


Commercial frags scale back naturals fairly aggressively in a large part due to cost. Vetivers fairly cheap, but compared to like iso e, it's positively a luxury. If you wanted to keep the vetiver note, you absolutely could keep it fairly easily. It's fairly bold and tenacous, so it doesn't easily get stomped out or pushed to the back unless you scale it way back. Could also look at synthetic components in the same realm to augment, veriveryl acetate is pretty common and could yield interesting results. Mostly natural derived fraction just acetic acid reacted iirc.. so depending on your strictness of definition, natural anyway.

I agree that a lot of commercial frags take liberties with notes, 'sandalwood' note is some weird idealized version that's just weird and goes pickley. 'oud' note is ... Not oudy. And so on. Patchouli is almost always hidden away to a whisper. It's not that synths overpowered them, but that the perfumer desired them to be the way they turned out.
All I can say is that my GCMS data is far more extensive than you imagine. I just want to offer Joe some advice: natural products have their limitations.
 
Commercial frags scale back naturals fairly aggressively in a large part due to cost. Vetivers fairly cheap, but compared to like iso e, it's positively a luxury. If you wanted to keep the vetiver note, you absolutely could keep it fairly easily. It's fairly bold and tenacous, so it doesn't easily get stomped out or pushed to the back unless you scale it way back. Could also look at synthetic components in the same realm to augment, veriveryl acetate is pretty common and could yield interesting results. Mostly natural derived fraction just acetic acid reacted iirc.. so depending on your strictness of definition, natural anyway.

I agree that a lot of commercial frags take liberties with notes, 'sandalwood' note is some weird idealized version that's just weird and goes pickley. 'oud' note is ... Not oudy. And so on. Patchouli is almost always hidden away to a whisper. It's not that synths overpowered them, but that the perfumer desired them to be the way they turned out.
Yes, i should try to source some of that vintage Guerlain Vetiver i have been reading about to see what it does with the original botanical. 'Somewhat' cheaper to just run some experiments with a single accord of Madagascar vetiver and vetiveryl acetate (and less risk of getting conned 🙂)..

Yeah, those liberties, yet people respond to such frag like 'lovely patchouli, takes me straight back to the seventies' - then i sniff and am like err, what patchouli? 🤷

So i would love to figure out how the praise of the vetiver note in that early Vetiver relates to the actual scent of vetiver..
 
Last edited:
Instantly in love ❤️ what a beautiful scent

View attachment 56737
Anthoxanthum Odoratum (sweet fernal grass) absolue, Biolandes

View attachment 56738
May I ask, through which vendor do you buy 'Biolandes' materials? They have something very particular, and rare, I want - for what I am on the hunt, not so successfully so far - since they do not deal directly - neither with private individuals nor with small-scale suppliers; and I can not find any vendors in EU who sell their whole range.
Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Top