You know, @Karim Collects , I've never tried an EO oud before?
Perfectly good oud, absurdly hyped, with unknown and untested purity as far as I know (no COA / GCMS reports, which is typical for oud retail). Keep in mind the flagship of this brand over all these years was an SQ oil. Nothing wrong with that at all, I would be proud to have tracked down and offered that oil, just saying this brand is on the same playing field as everybody else when you start looking a little deeper. If you like the offerings and the style and the approach, you can get good oud from them no doubt. I would love to see some blind GCMS tests though...
 
Last edited:
Perfectly good oud, absurdly hyped, with unknown and untested purity as far as I know (no COA / GCMS reports, which is typical for oud retail). Keep in mind the flagship of this brand over all these years was an SQ oil. nothing wrong with that at all, just saying this brand is on the same playing field as everybody else when you start looking a little deeper. If you like the offerings and the style and the approach, you can get good oud from them no doubt. I would love to see some blind GCMS tests though...
Blind GCMS on 1000 plus per g oils ,will be very difficult to achieve . In my personal years of collecting oils I have not seen a vendor providing this info.
I trust the vendors on the forum ,and still buy their oils without asking for gcms .
As for SQ oils thats a different story all together. They really need to be tested first as they are most likely the most adulterated product out there.
 
Blind GCMS on 1000 plus per g oils ,will be very difficult to achieve . In my personal years of collecting oils I have not seen a vendor providing this info.
I trust the vendors on the forum ,and still buy their oils without asking for gcms .
As for SQ oils thats a different story all together. They really need to be tested first as they are most likely the most adulterated product out there.
Are there vendors whom you trust for SQ oils?
 
Blind GCMS on 1000 plus per g oils ,will be very difficult to achieve . In my personal years of collecting oils I have not seen a vendor providing this info.
I trust the vendors on the forum ,and still buy their oils without asking for gcms .
As for SQ oils thats a different story all together. They really need to be tested first as they are most likely the most adulterated product out there.
Yep! In fact that is exactly what I was pointing out… "no COA / GCMS reports, which is typical for oud retail"


Here is a vendor who has been providing GCMS:

Eden Botanicals Agarwood

The issue is a complicated one especially for small vendors but the barriers to this are getting smaller every day and I have a feeling we will turn a corner in this area pretty soon.

it would be interesting to see if the SQ oils are actually anymore adulterated than any others on the market - I guess whenever some product or region or source has a perceived high value there will be efforts to cheat!
 
Last edited:
Perfectly good oud, absurdly hyped, with unknown and untested purity as far as I know (no COA / GCMS reports, which is typical for oud retail). Keep in mind the flagship of this brand over all these years was an SQ oil. Nothing wrong with that at all, I would be proud to have tracked down and offered that oil, just saying this brand is on the same playing field as everybody else when you start looking a little deeper. If you like the offerings and the style and the approach, you can get good oud from them no doubt. I would love to see some blind GCMS tests though...
a very interesting take
 
Perfectly good oud, absurdly hyped, with unknown and untested purity as far as I know (no COA / GCMS reports, which is typical for oud retail). Keep in mind the flagship of this brand over all these years was an SQ oil. Nothing wrong with that at all, I would be proud to have tracked down and offered that oil, just saying this brand is on the same playing field as everybody else when you start looking a little deeper. If you like the offerings and the style and the approach, you can get good oud from them no doubt. I would love to see some blind GCMS tests though...
Well, I believe this comment is loaded - maybe yes maybe no but I’ll give it my thoughts.

When you’re buying oils from vendors from the forum or outside I don’t think it’s feasible to expect a GCMS test. Would it be nice? Of course no doubt.

“Absurdly hyped, unknown and untested purity” that’s a strong claim - if this is being said due a past experience please shed some light on it so we can all learn. Otherwise this comment can be said about all vendors. On that note, if this is the “seal of approval” - I suggest all Ouddict vendors to have a GCMS section within their vendors thread on the main page with GCMS testing of all their offerings. That would be great.
 
Well, I believe this comment is loaded - maybe yes maybe no but I’ll give it my thoughts.

When you’re buying oils from vendors from the forum or outside I don’t think it’s feasible to expect a GCMS test. Would it be nice? Of course no doubt.

“Absurdly hyped, unknown and untested purity” that’s a strong claim - if this is being said due a past experience please shed some light on it so we can all learn. Otherwise this comment can be said about all vendors. On that note, if this is the “seal of approval” - I suggest all Ouddict vendors to have a GCMS section within their vendors thread on the main page with GCMS testing of all their offerings. That would be great.
It was loaded for sure in the sense that I was trying to make the point that it's just another brand offering a range of quality oils on par with other premium vendors, and may suit your fancy just fine and may not.

I felt compelled to make that point just because I occasionally see some statements that are over the top and never know quite how to react.

I think part of the reality is that having a GCMS report has not been that valuable in the trade so far because of who is using the tech - Eden offers them but I recognize people aren't swooping over to buy their agarwood just because it has no obvious diluents... that's not a guarantee that the oil is a good quality from the perspective of a collector of fragrance. I know this is all obvious to old time collectors... I have been accumulating specimens for years with the assumption that they were all somewhat stretched, even though I believed the people reselling them were earnest in their efforts to find pure stuff to the best of their ability without relying on testing, and to sell exactly what was sold to them.

Right now it seems customers have this choice to steer clear of the garbage:

1. Industrial scale products with testing

2. Luxury products from vendors with reputations, passing through multiple hands, with an element of uncertainty depending on the chain of custody

3. Luxury products direct from distillers (sort of a special category of the 2nd item)

All of this depends on trust being able to be established between two people of course. i'm guessing in the near future we're going to see another category which is luxury products with GCMS testing.

I state all of this just as an opinion, based on the limited information I've been able to gather as a consumer, far from the origins. Take with a grain of salt and feel free to correct or point out any misunderstandings I have here.
 
Last edited:
Enjoying a swipe of super hoi an - always feels like a little indulgence when I do
 
also swiped a CK distillate from broadlink - nothing fancy but it seems authentic. I keep checking on it hoping the top notes will improve a little bit but this is one that is really quite enjoyable and comparable to more expensive oils for the second half of the show, but a little bit cloying for the opening. Wish I could get over those top notes...
 
“Absurdly hyped, unknown and untested purity” that’s a strong claim - if this is being said due a past experience please shed some light on it so we can all learn.

I don't believe they offer GCMS testing so I just assume it's not tested - you'd think someone would share that information if it were as it would differentiate and add tangible value to a product? so that comment was only with respect to the discussion about GCMS testing
itself.

By absurdly hyped I mean there were times where it seemed like the online fan base kind of behaved as if it was the only credible source for high-quality stuff... yet we have things like oud royale being one in a lineup of SQ oils which are in fact not exclusive to anybody other than the SQ

This brand started with some rough products that were not authentic on ebay, and gradually came to bring high-quality material to the table, in line with other vendors who have had to go through their own learning curves. So not overhyped in terms of being lower quality than other premium vendors, but overhyped in terms of the echoing of ad copt that it was somehow on a tier of its own. there is a history of a western fan base who seemed (to me) to buy certain marketing lines hook line and sinker... it created this kind of disinformation bubble. I could be wrong
 
Last edited:
also swiped a CK distillate from broadlink - nothing fancy but it seems authentic. I keep checking on it hoping the top notes will improve a little bit but this is one that is really quite enjoyable and comparable to more expensive oils for the second half of the show, but a little bit cloying for the opening. Wish I could get over those top notes...
I have my own distilled 2022 CK whose top notes changed from mentholic to something more complex, like vietnamese or Hainanese.
 
Qasr AlOrchid - Malaysian Oud

Well this is a disappointment. The Oud smells completely of peanuts. I’ve had peanut smelling Vietnamese Oud before from EO but it was never this harsh. Very pungent too. I will be avoiding this.
 

Attachments

  • [Ouddict.com] Oud of the Day
    Orchid Malaysian.webp
    55.3 KB · Views: 72
Qasr AlOrchid - Malaysian Oud

Well this is a disappointment. The Oud smells completely of peanuts. I’ve had peanut smelling Vietnamese Oud before from EO but it was never this harsh. Very pungent too. I will be avoiding this.
yeah I've experienced that in some borneo oils as well. when it's too strong it's very hard to get past it. i wonder what the cause is?
 
I have my own distilled 2022 CK whose top notes changed from mentholic to something more complex, like vietnamese or Hainanese.
yes yours was appealing from top to bottom.

This has this strange plastic like opening that reminds me of plantation crassna a bit.

I have a little bit from the end of an older batch of theirs and that had either started or become more pleasant and cedar like in the top notes. I was hoping this one would eventually become that way but so far no dice. Seems that that delicate artisanal distillation pays off
 
Back
Top