I
It was loaded for sure in the sense that I was trying to make the point that it's just another brand offering a range of quality oils on par with other premium vendors, and may suit your fancy just fine and may not.

I felt compelled to make that point just because I occasionally see some statements that are over the top and never know quite how to react.

I think part of the reality is that having a GCMS report has not been that valuable in the trade so far because of who is using the tech - Eden offers them but I recognize people aren't swooping over to buy their agarwood just because it has no obvious diluents... that's not a guarantee that the oil is a good quality from the perspective of a collector of fragrance. I know this is all obvious to old time collectors... I have been accumulating specimens for years with the assumption that they were all somewhat stretched, even though I believed the people reselling them were earnest in their efforts to find pure stuff to the best of their ability without relying on testing, and to sell exactly what was sold to them.

Right now it seems customers have this choice to steer clear of the garbage:

1. Industrial scale products with testing

2. Luxury products from vendors with reputations, passing through multiple hands, with an element of uncertainty depending on the chain of custody

3. Luxury products direct from distillers (sort of a special category of the 2nd item)

All of this depends on trust being able to be established between two people of course. i'm guessing in the near future we're going to see another category which is luxury products with GCMS testing.

I state all of this just as an opinion, based on the limited information I've been able to gather as a consumer, far from the origins. Take with a grain of salt and feel free to correct or point out any misunderstandings I have here.
Btw dont get the wrong idea , I do agree that Ensar is hyped, most of the oils I bought were either not his or ok for the price.
 
I

Btw dont get the wrong idea , I do agree that Ensar is hyped, most of the oils I bought were either not his or ok for the price.
Got it - I think it was someone else I was responding to... someone had asked what I meant when I said the brand was overhyped and not offering tested oils. I don't mean to go on and on but probably was a good to clarify. If that someone was you, I guess I'm doubly confused ha ha.
 
Got it - I think it was someone else I was responding to... someone had asked what I meant when I said the brand was overhyped and not offering tested oils. I don't mean to go on and on but probably was a good to clarify. If that someone was you, I guess I'm doubly confused ha ha.
It is always fun to discuss the products .
Yesterday PNG TOL vs PNG alhashimi
They have similar openings of all spice floral wood ,but TOL has a more olde furniture wood type of smell , whilst alhashimi wears more like a perfume lacking the old wood smell.
I definitely prefer Alhashimi.
 
EO Suriranka 2.0

I absolutely just love this oil… Scored this from a private collector.
Seems overall I love oils from this region.
Is this a Walla Patta? One thing I've noticed in the Walla Patta oils that I have smelled is a kind of fusion of two region types - opening reminds me of
some classic indonesian island gaharu, and the second half reminds me specifically of Borneo oils, in particular some oils billed as originating in Malinau. really they have so much character and I can see why people might seek this region in particular.
 
5% dilution of distilled Hainan CK oil has aged really nicely - thick rich honey and something like acacia and light pepper. I only have a quarter tola of that oil, that's one I wish I had more of. Got it from Wardlab.
 
SQ Meghalaya 1977. “This is not a hindi” thats what you will say when you smell the opening. Absolutely no barn. Infact to my nose the opening is slightly similar to Malay Ultime. The dry down is most mesmerizing. Smell of old dusty books and a sweet incense wafting through.
 
Habz' Cambodi called Qazah, lovely non-fruity berried Cambodi which makes it quite different! Not too sweet

Yesterday was MesOud's Tarakhan for like the 4th wearing since owning it, which is unusual for me - it's usually a wear once and forget about it for a few months (not on purpose!)
Absolutely phenomenal oil! Hits all the right spots all at once. I'm blown away
 
Fushigi Oud - Lan Xang (Laos). Lovely! The oils from him all have a very similar vibe, I assume this is Crassna - am getting a kinda peanuty vibe to it which I sometimes like and other times not - depends on the oil
I was getting a peanut opening on a Thai oil I was wearing this morning. I really don't mind it. This is the only oud I have though with that peanut note in it so I can't compare with anything else. I can see how it could become a bit much.
 
I was getting a peanut opening on a Thai oil I was wearing this morning. I really don't mind it. This is the only oud I have though with that peanut note in it so I can't compare with anything else. I can see how it could become a bit much.
was very prominent in one of the first Imperial Oud oils I had - Fragrant Harbour Supreme. Wasn't a fan of it here and ended up selling it ....I wonder how that smells now - over 7 years since I bought it (wow I've been "into" oud that long. Crazy)
 
I was getting a peanut opening on a Thai oil I was wearing this morning. I really don't mind it. This is the only oud I have though with that peanut note in it so I can't compare with anything else. I can see how it could become a bit much.
interesting that it's showing up in a thai oil - previously I had only seen this in indonesian oil, usually Borneo. this suggests maybe it's related to technique as opposed to some regional variety of agarwood tree...
 
Back
Top