I can't understate this enough, and sometimes I struggle to articulate it, but truly doctor saab's works are unique to the extent I've never smelled anything like them before! What's even more challenging is, I outright love almost everything I've encountered of his! Those blends I don't, aren't even the entire blends but aspects of a portion of them which I find, stopping me from describing them as a "love" as opposed to "liking very much". How he handles florals and spices, sometimes I've approached blends of his which I thought would've had an overdose of this note or that, yet they never do! Then there's his use of animalics which always achieves the precise measure I enjoy, so that it never feels overlooked, nor overly pungent!

My experience can be summarized as the following, I've never sniffed nor applied one of this blends, and not had my mood instantly uplifted!
Is he only on instagram?
 
I have been pretty absent. But after grabbing a gram of Jupien and @Joe graciously included a sample of an unreleased attar (?). I had to try this "Oud Brother" and man is it something! medicinal oudy minty green opening and then the roses make themselves known, dense and luscious, bouncing against the oud and making something exceptional. Hope to see this released!
 
I have been pretty absent. But after grabbing a gram of Jupien and @Joe graciously included a sample of an unreleased attar (?). I had to try this "Oud Brother" and man is it something! medicinal oudy minty green opening and then the roses make themselves known, dense and luscious, bouncing against the oud and making something exceptional. Hope to see this released!
Thank you for your kind words. It will be released soon!
 
I recently received my order from Scent Talks, 3 attars: King Sa'ud Civet Oud Edition, The Black Stone, and Ghaliya Afzal.

King Sa'ud impressed me greatly with its high-quality Hindi oud, powerful! As for the civet, I was expecting something more animalic, but it turned out to be very well balanced. Without a doubt, my favorite!

The Black Stone and Ghaliya Afzal follow the same style as King Sa'ud, offering extremely high quality. Both are addictive. The musk is very prominent and well balanced, always in great harmony with the oud. All of them have strong projection and longevity. I am very happy to have the opportunity to experience Scent Talks attars, and I look forward to making new purchases soon.
 
Elecampane tincture at the moment. Farinaceous at first, then maple, walnuts, orris, and violet in a nice balance.
 
Scent Talks - The Black Stone w/Lux Vetiver II

I keep coming back to Scent Talks’ attars with great and anticipation and am never disappointed in an anti-climax fashion. It’s less about what the ingredients are and more about how the ingredients are blended. He can give you the proportions confidently but knows that there is no way in hell you’ll know how to blend it the way he does.

I have added a sample of Lux Vetiver II to add a grassy, and vegetative edge to uplift the scent with something green. It works well. But I think I prefer the hot rose III in combination with any of his attars.

So what I end up getting is a slightly animalic, warm, cinnamon, sweet oudy, and festively spicy concoction. Kudos!
 

Attachments

  • [Ouddict.com] Attar/Mukhallat of the Day
    The black stone and vetiver.webp
    62.3 KB · Views: 55
Majid Itirji "100% pure natural ambergris" oil

Notice the thick carpet of white ambroxide crystals on the bottom, smell the whalloping bouquet of clary sage oil and synthetic ambroxide, regret your purchase!

I was a fool to have purchased it but I believed their earnest fairytales - caveat emptor and though I was robbed by these guys maybe it is healthier to look at them as my teachers: I learned a lesson from them, had to learn it one way or another, the tuition was the cost of this bottle of fake ambergris and their fake chemical "100% pure and natural" musk oil I got with it. I see they still have the same products for sale, I attached snapshots.
IMG_4180.jpeg
IMG_4181.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • [Ouddict.com] Attar/Mukhallat of the Day
    IMG_4184.webp
    50.1 KB · Views: 61
  • [Ouddict.com] Attar/Mukhallat of the Day
    IMG_4182.webp
    32.5 KB · Views: 63
Last edited:
Majid Itirji "100% pure natural ambergris" oil

Notice the thick carpet of white ambroxide crystals on the bottom, smell the whalloping bouquet of clary sage oil and synthetic ambroxide, regret your purchase! I was a fool to have purchased it but I believed their earnest fairytales.

Definitely caveat emptor, I was robbed by these guys. healthier to look at them as my teachers: I learned a lesson from them, had to learn it one way or another, the tuition was the cost of this bottle of fake ambergris and their fake chemical "100% pure and natural" musk oil I got with it. I see they still have the same products for sale, I attached snapshots.View attachment 51786View attachment 51787
Gross and shameful.
Many scammers selling the same nonsense in India as well.
A very valuable post to the newbie and the uninitiated.
This forum needs more frank, educational posts like this.
 
Today is my first test of Zakir Gafur - Duja, which is an unreleased attar that was sold in conjunction with a recent elixir release, Abode of Clouds, which I will review soon as well. Duja is primarily honey and cedarwood, anchored with crassna oud, patchouli, and sandalwood. There is the zakir gafur "signature" that smells of rose, vanilla, and saffron blended to a luxurious smoothness. This oil is potent and sweet and a great easy wearing attar.
 
Al Bayt Al Ateeq II from ASO

Received a small sample thanks to a generous ouddict. I have only worn small dots of this so far so my impression reflects this lighter application. I did a little digging but could not immediately find any information on its composition. I'm sure something is out there - perhaps under the description of the original release?

I am struck by the unreal performance of what I assume is the interplay of musk, ambergris, oud, and rose - tiny little swipes of this left a long lasting mark, and the aroma was complex and addictive.

I get the impression a relatively robust and agrestic oud was used - these types of oils have a very long lasting presence on skin, and I imagine some of the magic of this blend comes from this and the ambergris putting down a long smooth but naturalistic carpet or foundation for the rest of the fragrance to ride along on.

Powerful stuff that reminds me of some Ghaliyas I have smelled... in fact I'm guessing that this could be considered a type of ghaliya? don't wear a lot of this type of fragrance so I don't feel qualified to evaluate it relative to any others in its class, but it feels like a real classic scent, and like a very effective application of the raw materials - a really good demonstration of the unique fixative power of ambergris, musk and oud, and also of the ability of Rose to instill a sense of charm. I suck at teasing out the subtle nuances of these animalic attars, so I'm not going to venture a guess at what is in this besides the four that I mentioned (musk, oud, ambergris, rose).
 
Al Bayt Al Ateeq II from ASO

Received a small sample thanks to a generous ouddict. I have only worn small dots of this so far so my impression reflects this lighter application. I did a little digging but could not immediately find any information on its composition. I'm sure something is out there - perhaps under the description of the original release?

I am struck by the unreal performance of what I assume is the interplay of musk, ambergris, oud, and rose - tiny little swipes of this left a long lasting mark, and the aroma was complex and addictive.

I get the impression a relatively robust and agrestic oud was used - these types of oils have a very long lasting presence on skin, and I imagine some of the magic of this blend comes from this and the ambergris putting down a long smooth but naturalistic carpet or foundation for the rest of the fragrance to ride along on.

Powerful stuff that reminds me of some Ghaliyas I have smelled... in fact I'm guessing that this could be considered a type of ghaliya? don't wear a lot of this type of fragrance so I don't feel qualified to evaluate it relative to any others in its class, but it feels like a real classic scent, and like a very effective application of the raw materials - a really good demonstration of the unique fixative power of ambergris, musk and oud, and also of the ability of Rose to instill a sense of charm. I suck at teasing out the subtle nuances of these animalic attars, so I'm not going to venture a guess at what is in this besides the four that I mentioned (musk, oud, ambergris, rose).
I’ve been looking forward to trying this for awhile! Can’t wait to order this!!
 
OK it's a strong smelling Middle Eastern style musk SmackDown.

Two versions of the Ajmal AA musk gazelle (older and younger) and the Majid Itrji Red "pure" musk oil.

I'll get the Majid out of the way: it smells strongly of violet leaf absolute cucumber and baby powder and a certain pretty strong musky facet that smells largely synthetic but could theoretically have some proportion of natural musk in it. It's not an unpleasant aroma, I actually think violet leaf combines nicely with musk, but it is a very far thing from a natural musk.

The older Ajmal AA is excellent stuff. I have no idea if it's touched up with synthetic and how much natural musk is in there versus castoreum (I think this definitely has a bit of that ) and other things. A touch of it produces a truly delicious enticing addictive spicy musky resinous aroma, it layers disturbingly well with agarwood oil. there's an almost soapy quality to it initially after application but the transition to the resin musk and wood is pretty rapid.

The slightly more recent Ajmal AA which is still one of the old ones, is very similar to the previous but there's a little more pronounced emphasis of some sweet and honey like qualities, some shifting balance relative to the previous batch. very similar oil, same ridiculously over the top strong musky presence, but it comes off as perhaps a little less resinous. My olfactory system is blown out at this point… this stuff is so strong.

I'm not a connoisseur / collector of musks or musk mukhallats, but I recall that people with experience appreciated the aroma of this so I have always taken it as a kind of benchmark mystery musky mixture. not sure what the reality is. Whatever this is it's not close to a straight up infusion of musk into a neutral carrier. Smells like it could have musk in it, and does not have the chemical white musk smell of the Majid oil.

IMG_4257.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top