Ahmaoud
True Ouddict
Thanks for sharing this comparison, I was thinking about getting a sample of Suriranka but having tried both Silani Sultan and Silani Royale both from TheAttarStore I think I'll pass on it.Nice write ups, thanks for sharing your thoughts on there.
I tend to agree about Kyara Ketone as well, which is why I sold mine years ago. The premise of it sounded really quite exciting but in the end it struck me as too one dimensional and almost....generic?
I have some of Silani sultan from the attar store it is more what I had hoped KK would be. It has the fuming, loud, and crystalline structure of what we associated with "the oriscent treatment" AND the depth and body of something like suriranka. Although a bit more aquatic and earty and a touch less floral than suriranka. It is an extremely potent, loud, and long lasting oil. I have noticed that many Sri Lankan oils have this character as a baseline but this distillation style takes it to another level.
I feel like both oils are quite similar but the opening of Silani Royale ... is just something from another planet! Punchy, blue green, almost petrochemical like fumes instantly assault your nose, yet clean, crystalline, and refreshing! Upon application it morphs continuously on my skin, and I totally agree, the longevity and projection on these ouds is in a class of their own. A single dot on my wrist from a glass rod, that barely touched the surface of the oil was enough to experience wafts, hours later! Though within about 3 - 4 hours Silani Royale does transition to the heart of Silani Sultan, the first portion of its scent is really something else, and faint hints can be experienced into the dry down.
My recent obsession's been with TheOudLab's Sirindica, a Silani and Manipur codistillation which has been exceedingly hard to decipher. From the cap it smells one way, and you think you know what you'll be getting, but dab a little, and spread, and something different emerges. Imagine that crystalline Silani profile but now sitting on a resinous base, I keep on wanting to type, fat, dense resinous base, yet the green airiness still comes through, slightly bitter with a tinge of smoke. Green resinous incense smoke, there's not better way to put it. I don't believe the Manipur alters the character of the Silani, if anything it feels fuller (akin to comparing HabzOud's Sultan Al Akhdar to AlShareefOudh's A'meen), perhaps boosting the incense-y qualities. And now my arms are tired from sniffing 😂 until next time!
