It's precisely this secrecy and the claims of unique methods among those selling acquired older oils that make Mehmet's work so interesting to me! It allows me to see for myself what happens when oils age...
I imagine it's good for everybody because we all get a chance to see the benefits of aging this way, and if all is as it should be it will help all of us to appreciate the benefits of carefully matured oud as well. And I actually think it's a very simple matter to safely store an oil to ensure beautiful maturation (i'd be very interested in any specific information about techniques of course).
I see a couple of problems in your approach here, first, your assumption that your aging and a professionals aging would lead to the same results. From what I have read in your posts you are basically just leaving it in the vial/bottle to 'age'.
Secondly, the assertion that everyone who ages oils has acquired those oils elsewhere rather than distilled them and aged themselves, is somewhat denying the process where a process exists that you simply aren't aware of.
The reality is aging is a proven art not only in oudh oils but also with other goods such as wine, meat, China bone etc.
I have written about curing and aging here before, if I remember correctly it's in my Distillation thread.
Aging isn't just about sitting the oil on the shelf and waiting for them to 'age'. Aging requires the initial oil to be understood and studied and the appropriate aging processed applied. Not all oils are aged the same way.
I read in one of your posts that in the last 25years you had made a certain number of findings, one of your findings was that you saw least amount of change in Hindi oils. This is completely opposite to facts and reality. Hindi oils change the most, they just take long to age and require certain specific parameters when being aged.
This is for a number of reasons but the main being, hindi oils have a higher moisture retention within the molecules of the oil, which doesn't separate into layers. The oil visibly is uniform, no sign of water. However similar to olive oil (just an example of retention not kind as olives are generally pressed), there is moisture present. This is why you find distillers in India, store the oils with open lids, this isn't to alter the smell artificially it is to try and dry it.
Just as a matter of distinction and so that in the future yourself and others don't draw us under the same stroke of the brush (generalising is not good about anyone but others can speak for themselves) we have oils that we distilled in house, that range from a few months to over 110 years, each oil aging in the unique way that is best suited for that oil.
Now in support of your thinking and one of the reasons someone like me is so sceptical of other old oils in the market such as the sq, etc, they do not present the signs of an aged oil for the years that they claim, even if just left in a bottle on a shelf. Even such a simple approach does bring certain distinct changes.
The final point, aging a 0.2ml vial 0r 3ml bottle on the shelf is very different than aging 100ml or 500ml.