I am not commenting on the SP attars which I have not experienced but just the concept of loudness in perfume in general. "Loudness" as a desirable characteristic has me a little bit stressed as a hopeful perfume maker, to be honest. Feel a little funny talking about it because I would not want to be taking a dig at somebody else's style, which may well be appreciated by many or possibly the majority of people.
For me, the loud perfumes are to be approached with protective gear and tongs, lightly sprayed on a piece of paper out of doors, well away from open doors or windows, and sniffed from a safe distance so as not to blow out the entire olfactory system etc. lol
So I accept that loud perfume is valued and has its application, and making it requires skill, AND I wonder to what degree there's an appreciation for things that are more naturalistic and close lying?